Silent Auction 2025 is Now Open! View Items & Bid

35 Years of Award-Winning Performances
View Timeline

Past Performances

Celebrating 35 Years of Award-winning performances IN SAG HARBOR

Since 1993, Bay Street Theater has been a beacon and a home for live theater. Many of the productions that have premiered or were developed at Bay Street Theater have moved to Broadway, Off-Broadway, regionally and abroad. 

    2020s

  • Bonkers in the Boroughs

    Book by Joy Behar

    Featured Cast

    Written by Joy Behar

    Bonkers in the Boroughs is a world premiere comedy comprised of five original short plays starring Joy Behar and friends. Sharp, fearless, and laugh-out-loud funny, the production takes a candid look at relationships and the everyday absurdities of New York life, finding connection through humor performed live and up close.

  • Dear Evan Hansen

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Book by Steven Levenson

    Lyrics by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul

    Music by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul

    Featured Cast

    Co-production with A.C.T. of Connecticut

    Winner of six Tony Awards including Best Musical, Dear Evan Hansen is a powerful and deeply human story of high schoolers and their parents seeking connection in a world that so desperately needs it. Directed by Bay Street Theater Artistic Director Scott Schwartz and featuring a stunning contemporary pop score, this reimagined production fully embraces the intimacy of the Bay Street space, giving voice to the hope, fear, and longing of being seen.

  • Cagney

    Directed by Will Pomerantz

    Book by Peter Colley

    Lyrics by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern

    Music by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern

    Featured Cast

    A Hollywood-Inspired Dance Musical

    June 30 – July 26, 2026

    Explosive and electric, Cagney brings Hollywood legend James Cagney to the stage through rhythm, song, and movement, celebrating his classic cinematic style. Directed by Bay Street Theater’s Associate Artistic Director Will Pomerantz (Evita, Ragtime at Bay Street Theater), executive produced by Kate Edelman Johnson and produced in association with Riki Kane Larimer, this high-energy dance musical captures the grit, charisma, and swagger that made Cagney an icon of the silver screen.

    Featuring music and lyrics by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern and a book by Peter Colley, Cagney The Musical blends original songs with beloved tunes by George M. Cohan, paying tribute to Cagney’s vaudeville roots and patriotic flair. From the intensity of his performances to the precision of his tap dancing, this vibrant production celebrates the drive and discipline behind one of Hollywood’s most unforgettable stars.

    Experience Cagney at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor, where this rhythm-fueled musical brings the Golden Age of film to life on the intimate Mainstage.

    Tickets are on sale now.

  • Mister Halston

    Directed by Michael Wilson

    Book by Raffaele Pacitti

    Featured Cast

    Produced in association with Tony Award–winning producer Bruce Robert Harris. Executive Producer: Donna Karan.

    Set against the glamorous and volatile worlds of 1970s and 80s New York and directed by Michael Wilson (Bay Street’s GREY GARDENS and FELLOW TRAVELERS), Mister Halston explores the meteoric rise, stunning fame, and ultimate fall of iconic American fashion designer Halston. In Bay Street’s intimate theater, the production offers a revealing portrait of the man behind the myth, stripping away spectacle to examine the human cost of ambition, artistry, and reinvention.

  • Deceived

    Written by Johnna Wright and Patty Jamieson

    Directed by Sheryl Kaller

    Adapted from Gaslight by Patrick Hamilton

    Featured Cast

    Mary Bacon, Briana Carlson-Goodman, Olivia Cygan, Sam Gravitte, Rebecca Salzhauer, Dayne Rasmussen

    This crackling new adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s Gaslight, streamlined to a cast of just four actors, reframes the story to strengthen and empower the central character of Bella. In this version of the classic suspense thriller, the audience wonders, “Can Bella find the strength to save herself?”

  • Fahrenheit 451 at Bay Street Theater

    Fahrenheit 451

    Directed by Stephen Hamilton

    Book by Ray Bradbury

    Featured Cast

    J.Stephen Brantley, Bonnie Comley, Matthew Conlon, Nicole Marie Hunt, John Kroft, Stewart F. Lane, Daniela Mastropietro, Dan Pavacic, Anna Francesca Schiavoni

    A Thrilling Sci-Fi Classic Lights Up the Stage

    Step into the world of Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451 as it blazes to life in a stunning new production at Bay Street Theater, directed by Stephen Hamilton.

    In this unforgettable science fiction play, firemen don’t fight fires…they start them. But when one man begins to question his role, he discovers the courage to think for himself and the power of imagination that can’t be extinguished.

    Visually striking and emotionally charged, Fahrenheit 451 invites audiences of all ages to experience Bradbury’s timeless story of discovery, courage, and hope. A captivating night of live theater that will spark conversation long after the curtain falls.

    Join us for a breathtaking adventure that celebrates the human spirit and the freedom to dream.

    Don’t miss this chance to experience one of the most powerful works of American literature on stage.

    With major support from the Alan & Annette Leve Family Foundation, initiated by Elise Leve

    Klingenstein-Martell Foundation

    Sunny and Abe Rosenberg Foundation

    Kenneth L. Grief Foundation

    The Neuwirth Foundation

    The Bridgehampton Association

    Town of Southampton

    Stony Brook Southampton Hospital

    Susan Dusenberry

    Nancy Stearns

    Riverhead Building Supply

    Tracy Semler

    Dan Terrasi & Mary Pagnotta

    Ed Littlefield

    RISK Strategies

  • Bob and Jean performance

    Bob & Jean: A Love Story

    Written by Robert Schenkkan

    Directed by Matt August

    Featured Cast

    Jake Bentley Young, Mary Mattison, Scott Wentworth

    Listen now to Pulitzer and Tony Award Winning Playwright, and author of Bob & Jean: A Love Story, Robert Schenkkan, on WLNG from Lunch on the Deck, Saturday May 2025

    Lightning strikes and sparks fly when Bob and Jean meet in New York City, 1941. But their instant attraction is cut short as World War II drives the pair thousands of miles apart. While Bob is off to the Pacific as a bomb disposal officer, Jean is headed to boost troop morale as a USO actress. Is their connection strong enough to withstand the winds of war? Travel through their passionate, funny, sometimes desperate correspondence as they navigate battle, Broadway, and the complexities of the human heart. A new play written by Pulitzer Prize- and Tony Award-winning and Emmy-nominated playwright Robert Schenkkan, “Bob & Jean: A Love Story” is a stirring and romantic world premiere that tells the remarkable story of an exhilarating courtship. Production photos: Tim Fuller

  • Bonnie & Clyde: The Musical

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Book by Ivan Menchell

    Lyrics by Don Black

    Music by Frank Wildhorn

    Featured Cast

    Gisela Adisa, Ashley Alexandra, Nick Bailey, Amy Bodnar, Anthony Costello, Kathy Deitch, Mackenzie Germain, Lyda Jade Harlan, Anargha Pal, Vishal Vaidya, Charlie Webb, Jeremy Webb

    Passion. Danger. Fame. Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow were anything but ordinary. She dreamed of Hollywood, he craved a life beyond the law, and together, they became the most notorious duo of their time. As they race toward fame and infamy, their passion burns as hot and fast as their V8 Ford. BONNIE AND CLYDE: THE MUSICAL ignites the stage with the fiery romance of America’s infamous young outlaws, blending passionate love with rebellion against the backdrop of the Great Depression. This award-nominated musical, in a bold new production directed by Bay Street’s Artistic Director Scott Schwartz and featuring a fiery score by Frank Wildhorn (Jekyll & Hyde, The Scarlet Pimpernel) and Don Black (Sunset Blvd, Aspects of Love), blends heart-stopping action with steamy romance, dark humor, and irresistible charm.

    Two small-town kids from the middle of nowhere became the biggest folk heroes in all America. They craved adventure—and each other. Their names were Bonnie and Clyde. Fearless, shameless, and alluring, this award-winning production has garnered a mass following, much like the infamous pair themselves, and now they are set to take your city by storm. Discover the electrifying story of love, adventure and crime that captured the attention of an entire nation.

  • A Streetcar Named Desire

    Written by Tennessee Williams

    Directed by Stephen Hamilton

    Featured Cast

    Katie Rodgers, Shea Buckner, Joe Pallister, Sawyer A. Spielberg, Nicole Marie Hunt, Carlos Garcia, Matthew Conlon, Daniela Mastropietro, Adelaide Mestre

    A powerful exploration of desire and mental fragility, following Blanche DuBois as she confronts her troubled past while residing with her sister Stella and brother-in-law Stanley in New Orleans. The play won the Pulitzer Prize for Drama in 1948 and has become a timeless classic, hailed for its profound impact on American theater. Streetcar, set in post-World War II New Orleans, chronicles the perilous journey of Blanche DuBois, the faded and delusional southern belle as she encounters her plain-speaking and often brutal brother-in-law, Stanley Kowalski.

  • The Subject Was Roses

    Written by Frank D. Gilroy

    Directed by Scott Wittman

    Featured Cast

    John Slattery, Talia Balsam, Harry Slattery

    Like roses, family relationships are beautiful but thorny. This Pulitzer Prize and two-time Tony Award-winning play is a poignant drama set in The Bronx in 1946 about the emotional struggles and hidden tensions within a family as their son returns from service in WWII. As they confront their past and present, this timeless play explores enduring themes of reconciliation and the fragility of love.

  • Masterclass

    Written by Terrence McNally

    Directed by Lisa Peterson

    Featured Cast

    Brett Ryback, Vicki Lewis, Stella Kim, Ben Rauch, Rodney Ingram, Olivia Hernandez

    A virtuosic exploration of art, ego, and the pursuit of perfection. In the waning years of her life and with her career far behind her, opera diva Maria Callas retreats into memories of acclaim and adversity while contending with her students during a funny and brutal master class in singing.

  • What I Know Now

    Written by Julia Motyka

    Directed by John Leonard Thompson

    Featured Cast

    Julia Motyka

    Life isn’t lived by the numbers. As she awaits the answer to one of life’s big questions, a woman explores the nature of faith and her own complicated family. The hit of the 2023 New Works Festival, this premiere from Bay Street favorite Julia Motyka wrestles with the seen and unseen forces that shape our lives.

  • Mel Brooks’ Young Frankenstein

    Written by Mel Brooks

    Directed by Gerry McIntyre

    Featured Cast

    Sean Bell, Aaron Choi, Savannah Cooper, Matthew Hydzik, Christin Emily Jackson, Bradley Gibbins-Klein, Brady Miller, Linda Neel, James Romney, Kyla Stone, Alena Watters, Cullen J Zeno, Veanne Cox, Chris McNiff

    The comedic genius of Mel Brooks combines with classic B-movie horror in this hilarious musical based on his beloved film. The young American doctor Frederick Frankenstein (“that’s pronounced Fronkensteen!”) is summoned to Transylvania to claim his Grandfather Victor’s estate. Little does he know that this journey will change not only his life, but those of everyone around him, including his sidekick Igor, the beautiful assistant Inga, and a brand-new Monster made for Musical Comedy Heaven.

  • Double Helix

    Written by Madeline Myers

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Anthony Chatmon II, Max Chlumecky, nthony Joseph Costello, Kate Fitzgerald, Amy Justman, Matthew Christian, Austin Ku, Thom Sesma, Tuck Sweeney, Ethan Yaheen-Moy Chan

    In the early 1950s, the race to discover the structure of DNA grips the scientific community. One brilliant young researcher, Rosalind Franklin, contends with adversity, anti-semitism, and love to uncover one of life’s great mysteries. But will she sacrifice what makes her human, in order to discover what makes us human?

  • Dial M for Murder

    Written by Frederick Knott

    Directed by Walter Bobbie

    Featured Cast

    Mamie Gummer, Rosa Gilmore, Erich Bergen, Max Gordon Moore, Reg Rogers

    An edge-of-your-seat, new adaptation of the celebrated suspense thriller made famous by Alfred Hitchcock’s 1954 masterpiece film. Tony suspects his wife, Margot—a wealthy socialite—is having an affair. As he plots to have her killed in this stylish game of cat and mouse, the tension grows, and the twists and turns will keep you guessing until the very end.

  • Tales from the Guttenburg Bible

    Written by Steve Guttenberg

    Directed by David Saint

    Featured Cast

    Carine Montbertrand, Steve Guttenberg, Stephen deRosa, Dan Domingues

    A farcical, laugh-out-loud story journeying from the Guttenberg’s family home on Long Island to the glamour of Hollywood as told by Stephen Guttenberg himself.

  • The Crucible

    Written by Arthur Miller

    Directed by Will Pomerantz

    Featured Cast

    Sonnie Betts, Matthew Conlon, Teresa DeBerry, Kate Fitzgerald, Meg Gibson, Allen O'Reilly, Joe Pallister, Gabriel Portundo, Keith Reddin, Anna Francesca Schiavoni

    Written in the early 1950s, Arthur Miller’s play “The Crucible” takes place in Salem, Massachusetts, during the 1692 Salem witch trials. This was a time when paranoia, hysteria, and deceit gripped the Puritan towns of New England. Miller captured the events in a riveting story that is now considered a modern classic in the theater. He wrote it during the “Red Scare” of the 1950s and used the Salem witch trials as a metaphor for the “witch hunts” of communists in America.

  • Anna In the Tropics

    Written by Nilo Cruz

    Directed by Marcos Santana

    Featured Cast

    Christian Barillas, Maria Isabel Bilbao, Serafin Falcon, Iliana Guibert, Guillermo Ivan, Antony Michael Marinez, Christine Spang

    Nilo Cruz’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play, Anna in the Tropics, centers on a sultry and steamy cigar factory in 1929 Tampa, Florida, where the lives of a Cuban-American family are challenged by the vices and temptations that surround them.

  • All Things Equal

    Written by Rupert Holmes

    Directed by Laly Lippard

    Featured Cast

    Supreme Court Justice “RBG” welcomes a friend of the family to her cozy chambers to convey, over the course of ninety fascinating and often funny minutes, a sense of her life and its many trials:

    ….losing her mother the day before she graduated as valedictorian of her Brooklyn high school

    … being one of only nine young women studying law at Harvard while also raising a daughter and helping her husband battle cancer

    … fighting for women’s rights in the nineteen-seventies before condescending all-male courts

    … and taking courageous stands for human rights as a voice of reason amid a splintering and increasingly politicized Supreme Court.

    An evening with a great and compassionate icon of straight-thinking American justice emerges, an RBG who is not only “notorious” but victorious as she takes a stand for ordinary people facing the many challenges of a changing world.

  • Ragtime

    Directed by Will Pomerantz

    Featured Cast

    Kyrie Courter, Derrick Davis, Lora Lee Gayer, Zachary Prince, Daniel Jenkins, Harrison Bryan, Davon Williams, Clyde Voce, Rachel Parker, Taylor Jackson, Cathryn Wake, Victoria Huston-Elem, Ryan M. Hunt, Cecelia Ticktin, Will Hantz, Sonnie Betts, Autumn Miller, Tatumn Miller

    Based on the novel of the same name by E.L. Doctrow, Ahren’s and Flaherty’s Ragtime is a compelling epic capturing the American experience at the turn of the 20th century. Tracking three diverse families in pursuit of the American dream in the volatile “melting pot” of turn-of-the-century New York, Ragtime confronts the dialectic contradictions inherent in American reality: experiences of wealth and poverty, freedom and prejudice, hope and despair. Over the course of the show, the worlds of a wealthy white couple, a Jewish immigrant father and his motherless daughter, and an African American ragtime musician intertwine. Together, they discover the surprising interconnections of the human heart, the limitations of justice and the unsettling consequences when dreams are permanently deferred. Featuring many of the historical figures that built and shaped turn-of-the-century America, including J.P. Morgan, Emma Goldman, Harry Houdini, Evelyn Nesbit and Henry Ford, this musical sweeps across the diversity of the American experience to create a stirring epic that captures the beats of the American experience: the marches, the cakewalks and – of course, the ragtime.

  • Windfall

    Written by Scooter Pietsch

    Directed by Jason Alexander

    Featured Cast

    Galvan Kidd, Kate Rearden, Glenn Brannon, Hannah Higley, Jaqueline Vanderbilt, Chris Hart

    Five office workers in Columbus, Ohio, toil under the heavy hand of a maniacal boss and dream of a better life. When the boss’s antics become too much to bear, they bet their every last cent on a one-billion-dollar lottery jackpot. But the prospect of winning brings out the worst in these best friends.

  • Frankenstein

    Written by Yee Eun Nam

    Featured Cast

    Kalyn West
  • 20,000

    Written by Mike Billings

    Featured Cast

    Cameron King, Peter Macklin, Julia Motyka, Will Pomerantz
  • Smile

    Written by Brittany Bland

    Featured Cast

    Herself
  • Camelot

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Kyle Lopez Barisich, Britney Coleman, Aaron Dalla Villa, Amaya Grier, Hope Hamilton, James Harkness, Deven Kolluri, Jeremy Kushnier, David Lamarr, Cecelia Ticktin, Kevin Wang

    This new envisioning of Camelot and the story of King Arthur, Guenevere, and Lancelot is told with intimacy, immediacy, and incandescent passion. The beloved musical explores one of the greatest romances of all time and paints a luminous picture of a fleeting moment when justice, peace, and righteousness reigned supreme.

    While that moment must come to an end, we are asked to believe it could come again. Love, loss, humor, and regret pour forth from the acclaimed score, which includes classic songs such as I Loved You Once in Silence, I Wonder What the King Is Doing Tonight, If Ever I Would Leave You and of course the title song, Camelot.

  • We Are in This Together, As Well As the Stages: Shutdown, Crisis, Restart

    Written by Rasean Davonte Johnson

    Featured Cast

    Himself
  • Becoming Dr. Ruth

    Written by Mark St. Germain

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Tovah Feldshuh

    Chronicling the life of noted psychologist Dr. Ruth Westheimer, from her early years fleeing Nazi Germany, living as an orphan in Switzerland, to her service in the Israeli armed forces as a sharpshooter, and her later life and career in New York. It is a humorous and heartfelt portrait detailing Dr. Ruth’s remarkable journey to become a pioneer in the psychology of human sexuality and the world’s most famous sex therapist.

  • Macbeth

    Featured Cast

  • Wonder Wall

    Featured Cast

  • Moby Dick

    Featured Cast

    2010s

  • Safe Space

    Written by Alan Fox

    Directed by Jack O’Brien

    Featured Cast

    Sasha Diamond, Rodney Richardson, Mercedes Ruehl

    Set at an elite university and explores political correctness and the reaction to triggers on campus in America today. When a star African-American professor faces accusations of racism from a student, the head of the college must intervene, setting off an explosive chain of events where each of them must navigate an ever-changing minefield of identity politics, ethics, and core beliefs.

  • A Raisin in the Sun

    Featured Cast

    A Raisin in the Sun teaches us about the value of dreaming big, the urgent need to fight racial discrimination, and the importance of family. Join the unforgettable members of the Younger family as they experience both tragedy and triumph in 1959 Chicago.

  • Annie Get Your Gun

    Directed by Sarna Lapine

    Featured Cast

    George Abud, Oge Agulue, Stephen Lee Anderson, Davis Macleod Haines, Will Hantz, Jonathan Joss, Meaghan McInnes, Orville Mendoza, Kara Mikula, Isa Mooney, Matthew Saldivar, Jennifer Sanchez, Alexandra Socha, Erica Spyres, Allison Walsh, Aidan Ziegler-Hansen

    Irving Berlin’s ANNIE GET YOUR GUN is one of the most beloved musicals of Broadway’s Golden Age. It tells the story of sharpshooter Annie Oakley, who starred in Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show, and her tempestuous romance with fellow sharpshooter Frank Butler.  Acclaimed director Sarna Lapine will bring a fresh, modern approach to the story, incorporating elements from Dorothy Fields’ original book to create the strongest and most revolutionary Annie Oakley you’ve ever seen.  This musical includes such beloved songs as There’s No Business Like Show Business, Anything You Can Do, and I Got Sun in the Morning which will be performed by a country western, bluegrass band.

  • The Prompter

    Written by Wade Dooley

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Wade Dooley, Tovah Feldshuh

    A legendary diva who forgets her lines. The non-famous, sometimes-actor paid to remember them. 

    By popular demand, the hit of Bay Street’s 2018 New Works Festival takes its premiere bow! THE PROMPTER follows veteran actress Irene Young, who, after a forty-year absence, is returning to the Broadway stage. But now, she can’t do it alone; so the production hires a young actor to be her prompter. But, this isn’t her story, it’s his. Based on real events, THE PROMPTER is a funny, heartfelt, untold, behind-the-scenes look at Broadway through the eyes of a young dreamer.

  • Fellow Travelers

    Written by Jack Canfora

    Directed by Michael Wilson

    Featured Cast

    Wayne Alan Wilcox, Rachel Spencer Hewitt, Vince Nappo, Mark Blum, Jeffrey Bean

    Set during Hollywood’s notorious Blacklist, FELLOW TRAVELERS examines the relationship between legendary theater artists Arthur Miller and Elia Kazan and their close connection to Marilyn Monroe. Kazan directed several Miller plays, including DEATH OF A SALESMAN, and Tennessee Williams dramas, including A STREETCAR  NAMED DESIRE. Miller also wrote the modern classics THE CRUCIBLE and A VIEW FROM THE BRIDGE. FELLOW TRAVELERS explores how the politics of the McCarthy era affected their friendship and how their friendship affected their work.

  • The Great Gatsby

    Featured Cast

    Set in the Jazz Age around New York City and the fictional Long Island towns of West Egg and East Egg, The Great Gatsby tells the story of Jay Gatsby, a self-made man who dreams of turning back time to regain his first love, Daisy Buchanan. In the process, the novel explores the culture of the Roaring Twenties, class in America, and the dangerous allure of the American Dream.

  • Frost/Nixon

    Written by Peter Morgan

    Directed by Sarna Lapine

    Featured Cast

    Daniel Gerroll Harris Yulin, Stephen Lee Anderson, Christian Conn, Michael Corvino, Brian Keane, Cici Koueth, Danielle Slavick, Rich Topol, Price Waldman

    FROST/NIXON revolves around the landmark series of interviews between British journalist David Frost and former President Nixon three years after he resigned. It’s a battle of wits that pits a broadcaster against one of America’s most complex and wily presidents; a riveting story of the collision of politics and the media.

  • Evita

    Directed by Will Pomerantz

    Featured Cast

    Arianna Rosario, Trent Saunders, Omar Lopez-Cepero, Kyle Barisich, Gabi Campo, Dakota Quackenbush, Julian Alvarez, Edgar Cavazos, Lauren Csete, Elisa Galindez, Juan Guillen, Jose Ozuna, Carolina Santos Read, Danelle Rivera

    The revival of the beloved musical EVITA, will take a new look at the iconic Eva Perón and her ascent to the top as the First Lady of Argentina. Bay Street Theater will offer its signature treatment of a large scale musical – an intimate experience in a thrust theater that allows the audience to get close to the iconic characters and dig deep into the world of and story of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s masterpiece. The classic score features some of Webber and Rice’s biggest hits, including “Don’t Cry for Me Argentina,” “High Flying, Adored” and “Another Suitcase in Another Hall.”

  • Intimate Apparel

    Written by Lynn Nottage

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Blake Delong, Julia Motyka, Portia, Kelly Mccreary, Edward O'blenis, Shayna Small

    It’s a delicate line between love and desire…

    Esther Mills is a skilled African American seamstress and has her own successful business in 1905 making lingerie for both society ladies and “ladies of the night.” But she is lonely. As she searches for something more in her life, she unearths truths long hidden in the deepest recesses of her heart. All her relationships will be changed forever, from a poetic love with a Caribbean laborer working far away on the Panama Canal, to complicated friendships with different women in her life, to a growing bond with a Hasidic shopkeeper who shares his exquisite finds of fabrics and maybe something deeper.

  • Death of a Salesman

    Featured Cast

    Death of a Salesman, considered to be one of the greatest plays of the 20th century, is a Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winning play written in 1949 by the renowned American playwright Arthur Miller. Set in the late 1940’s, Death of a Salesman follows Willy Loman, a failing salesman, and his family as they face the harsh reality of their lives that they have been denying. As Willy spirals into mental disarray and fails to achieve his own dreams, he criticizes his son Biff for not being successful. As Biff faces his own disappointments, he confronts the family on his father’s unrealistic expectations for him and his inability to face the truth about their lives. Ultimately, Miller explores themes surrounding the uncertainty of the American Dream and the struggles that families face in the wake of a changing economy, both of which are as contemporary today as when the play was written.

  • The Man in the Ceiling

    Directed by Jeffrey Seller

    Featured Cast

    Danny Binstock, Brett Gray, Andrew Lippa, Jonah Broscow, Erin Kommor, Nicole Parker
    His imagination is just what his family needs…Jimmy Jibbett is a boy cartoonist. A hopeless aptitude if you listen to his father, who wants Jimmy to play ball like a real boy. You’d think his mother would stick up for him, but she’s too busy, running here, there, everywhere. Besides, she’s got her brother Lester to worry about. He writes music also, but he can’t come up with a love song. So Jimmy’s only true support becomes the comics characters he invents until, one day, he discovers way up on the ceiling, something new and surprising that will change him and his family.
  • As You Like It

    Written by William Shakespeare

    Directed by John Doyle

    Featured Cast

    Quincy Tyler Bernstine, Ellen Burstyn, André De Shields, Leenya Rideout, Kyle Scatliffe, Noah Brody, Hannah Cabell, Cass Morgan, David Samuel, Bob Stillman

    Everyone needs to escape to the country sometimes! Join Rosalind, one of Shakespeare’s greatest heroines, as she travels into the merry Forest of Arden leaving behind the politics of the city. Disguising herself as a man and accompanied by her cousin Celia and Touchstone the clown, she embarks on a hilarious and romantic journey where she finds love, laughter, and maybe even herself. Shakespeare’s beloved comedy will be brought to joyful new life in a production filled with Jazz Era inspired music performed by a masterful cast.

  • My Fair Lady

    Directed by Michael Arden

    Featured Cast

    Paul Alexander Nolan, Kelli Barrett, Howard McGillin, Kyle Barisch, Jen Bechter, Roger E. Dewitt, Ryan Fitzgerald, Meghan Laflam, John O'Creagh, Mickey Rafalski, Karen Murphy, Lindsay Roberts, Bobby Conte Thornton, Bradley Allan Zarr, Carole Shelley

    When Eliza Doolittle, a cockney flower seller, meets the imperious and attractive Professor Henry Higgins one night in Covent Garden, they agree to embark on a daring experiment together. Higgins wagers that he can transform the “deliciously low” Eliza into a lady fit for society by teaching her to speak more beautifully. Sparks fly in what becomes a funny and ferocious battle of the sexes, a struggle of classes, and a rollicking romance. Acclaimed director Michael Arden’s innovative new production will feature two pianos and fifteen actors who will bring the classic story to life in ways you’ve never seen before.  One of the greatest musicals of time, with a magnificent score featuring the beloved songs “I Could Have Danced All Night,” “Wouldn’t It be Loverly” and “On the Street Where You Live,” this Fair Lady is a perfect musical for the whole family.

  • The Forgotten Woman

    Written by Jonathan Tolins

    Directed by Noah Himmelstein

    Featured Cast

    Ashlie Atkinson, Darren Goldstein, Mark Junek, Justin Mark, Robert Stanton

    Margaret Meier is a gifted soprano on the verge of a major operatic career.  And she’s terrified.  When a handsome reporter shows up at her Chicago hotel room, this anything-but-diva-like diva is forced to grapple with every aspect of her life: her less-than-passionate marriage, her child, her ambition, her weight, and the price she must pay in this most demanding and irrational art form. Will Margaret succeed in mastering her career, men, and her own self doubt to release the star within?

  • The Scarlet Letter

    Featured Cast

    Set in the 1600s in a Puritan village, THE SCARLET LETTER is an account of the life of Hester Prynne, a married woman who becomes a social outcast, when after an adulterous affair she conceives a daughter during her husband’s long absence. She is required to wear the letter “A” for adultery on the breast of her gown. Refusing to name the father, Hester is forced to live a life set apart from nearly everyone she knows. Thanks to the intervention of the Rev. Arthur Dimmesdale, Hester and her daughter Pearl are permitted to stay together. When Hester’s missing husband, posing as a doctor, secretly returns as Roger Chillingworth, the stage is set for a story of sin, tragedy, and redemption. This show explores themes of legalism, sin, and guilt.

  • The Last Night of Ballyhoo

    Written by Alfred Uhry

    Directed by Will Pomerantz

    Featured Cast

    Daniel Abeles, Ari Brand, Ellen Harvey, John Hickok, Dori Legg, Erin Neufer, Amanda Kristin Nichols

    Atlanta, 1939. The premiere of Gone with the Wind. The party of the year. And everything is about to change. The wealthy and important Freitag family is looking forward to Ballyhoo, the lavish German Jewish country club ball, and all it will mean for daughters Lala and Sunny. But life turns upside down when their uncle brings home his new employee, a handsome Eastern European bachelor from Brooklyn. Everyone must confront their own beliefs, prejudices, and desires. The family will never be the same as they take a journey filled with comedy, romance, and surprising revelations.

  • The New Sincerity

    Written by Alena Smith

    Directed by Bob Balaban

    Featured Cast

    Teddy Bergman, Peter Mark Kendall, Justine Lupe, Elvy Yost

    The story follows a nearly 30-year-old writer named Rose Spencer who has just begun working for a literary journal called Asymptote. Her editor, Benjamin, knows he’s working in a doomed industry, but he can’t escape the requirements that he publish the drivel requested by his silent partner, who controls the magazine’s finances, or the philosophical sway of his fiancée, Sadie, who believes all new social movements are doomed to failure. 

    When Rose suggests he allow her to cover the Occupy movement, Benjamin originally scoffs at the idea, then becomes excited by it, and then ends up taking credit for Asymptote’s role in the protest as it grows, morphs and eventually is cleared out of the park by the police. 

  • Five Presidents

    Written by Rick Cleveland

    Directed by Mark Clements

    Featured Cast

    John Bolger, Mark Jacoby, Martin L'herault, Reese Madigan, Steve Sheridan, Brit Whittle

    This funny and incisive new drama is about the meeting of America’s most exclusive club – the ex-presidents. Obligated to gather together on the day of Richard Nixon’s funeral, four “exes” and one “current” vent frustrations, revisit old grievances, and reveal the toll that it takes on any person foolish enough to seek the highest office in the land.

  • Grey Gardens: The Musical

    Written by David Maysles

    Written by Ellen Hovde

    Directed by Michael Wilson

    Featured Cast

    Rachel York, Betty Buckley, Matt Doyle, James Harkness, Sarah Hunt, Gracie Beardsley, Dakota Quackenbush, Simon Jones, Howard McGillin

    GREY GARDENS tells the story of Big Edie and Little Edie Bouvier Beale, the eccentric aunt and cousin of Jaqueline Kennedy Onassis. It is based on the 1975 documentary by Albert and David Maysles, which is celebrating its 40th anniversary in 2015. Set at the Bouvier mansion in East Hampton, this bold musical follows a mother and daughter on their hilarious and heartbreaking journey from glamorous aristocrats to notorious recluses in a crumbling house filled with memories and cats.

  • Of Mice and Men

    Featured Cast

    John Steinbeck’s classic American novel, Of Mice and Men is a compelling tale of friendship and survival in the time of the Great Depression. George and Lennie are two migrant farm workers who dream of one day owning their own piece of land. But when Lennie gets too close to the wife of the boss’s son, George must choose between protecting his friend and staying the course towards his version of the American Dream.

  • Travesties

    Written by Tom Stoppard

    Directed by Gregory Boyd

    Featured Cast

    Michael Benz, Carson Elrod, Aloysius Gigl, Isabel Keating, Richard Kind, Julia Motyka, Emily Trask, Andrew Weems

    This Tom Stoppard classic will be directed by Gregory Boyd. Stoppard creates a smashing theatrical extravaganza with the wit of Oscar Wilde crashing headlong into song-and-dance, strip-tease, pie-fights, and brilliant wordplay. Set in 1917 and 1974 in Zurich, Switzerland, the play fantasizes how a British consul named Henry Carr (Richard Kind) encounters some of the most famous figures of the 20th century, including James Joyce, Tristan Tzara and Lenin, through an amateur production of The Importance of Being Earnest. Stoppard takes on the role of the artist in society in this exuberant and freewheeling comedy about art and revolution that is as fresh and thought-provoking as it is uproarious.

  • To Kill a Mockingbird

    Featured Cast

    Set in Alabama in 1934, Harper Lee’s enduring story of racial injustice and childhood innocence centers on one of the most venerated characters in American literature, small-town lawyer Atticus Finch. He encourages kindness and empathy in his children, Scout and Jem, but is pushed to the limits of these qualities himself when he resolves to uncover the truth in a town that seems determined to hide it.

  • Conviction

    Written by Carey Crim

    Directed by Scott Schwartz

    Featured Cast

    Daniel Burns, Garret Dillahunt, Brian Hutchison, Sarah Paulson, Elizabeth Reaser

    The drama explores the effects on family, friendships and sense of self after the young actress playing Juliet in a high school performance of Romeo and Juliet accuses her teacher Tom of what the newspaper calls “an inappropriate sexual relationship with an underage female student.” The play focuses on the four adults and on Nicholas, the teenage son of Tom and his wife Leigh, as they cope with accusation and trust. The show asks an avalanche of questions from the obvious “did he or didn’t he?” characters also discuss what “underage” means, since different states have different definitions, and what should be considered inappropriate behavior for a teacher and student. There is further consideration of how much drug use a parent should tolerate in a teenager, what friendship is about, how far spousal allegiance should go and how much doubt an outsider to the family should express.

  • My Life Is a Musical

    Written by Adam Overett

    Directed by Marlo Hunter

    Featured Cast

    Wendi Bergamini, Robert Cuccioli, Adam Daveline, Danyel Fulton, Kathleen Elizabeth Monteleone, Justin Matthew Sargent, Brian Sills, Howie Michael Smith

    Parker is a shy accountant with a big secret: his life is a musical. While everyone else lives their normal lives, he sees them bursting into song and dance numbers, accompanied by an invisible orchestra. His worst fears are realized when his boss sends him on the road as a tour manager for a singer-songwriter named Zach—what if his bizarre condition is discovered?

    Instead, on the sly, Parker gives Zach the tunes from his own musical life…the tunes become hits, and Zach becomes a national sensation. J.T., Zach’s manager, is entranced by Zach’s newfound artistry and she starts to fall for him…while Parker finds himself falling for J.T. As the tour arrives on a national stage, Parker must choose whether to keep his secret, or the love of his life.

  • Lend Me a Tenor

    Written by Ken Ludwig

    Directed by Don Stephenson

    Featured Cast

    Judy Blazer, Scott Cote, Betsy DeLellio, Donna English, Nancy Johnston, Noah Plomgren, Steve Rosen, Roland Rusinek

    A fast-paced comedy set in a hotel suite in Cleveland, Ohio on the night of a major opera performance in 1934. The story revolves around the character Tito Merelli, a famous tenor who fails to appear, prompting a series of misunderstandings and chaotic events. The plot thickens as Max, a young man, is coerced into impersonating Tito to avoid financial losses from the audience’s tickets. This mistaken identity leads to humorous situations involving romantic entanglements and frantic attempts to manage the fallout.

  • The Mystery of Irma Vep

    Written by Christopher Durang

    Directed by Kenneth Elliott

    Featured Cast

    Tom Aulino, David Greenspan

    A satire of several theatrical, literary and film genres, including Victorian melodrama, farce, the penny dreadful, Wuthering Heights and the Alfred Hitchcock film Rebecca (1940). Mandacrest Estate is the home of Lord Edgar, an Egyptologist, and Lady Enid. Lady Enid is Lord Edgar’s second wife, though he has yet to recover entirely from the passing of his first wife, Irma Vep. The house staff, a maid named Jane Twisden and a swineherd named Nicodemus Underwood, have their own opinions of Lady Enid.

  • A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Jen Bechter, Halley Cianfarini, Jessica Crouch, Tom Deckman, Lora Lee Gayer, Glen Giron, Laurent Giroux, Shiloh Goodin, Nathaniel Hackmann, Grant Haralson, Jackie Hoffman, Stewart Lane, Terry Lavell, Phoebe Pearl, Conrad John Schuck, Peter Scolari, Nick Verina, J. Morgan White

    Pseudolus, a Roman slave who is yearning for his freedom, learns that his young master, Hero, is in love with Philia, a virgin courtesan from the house of Marcus Lycus. Pseudolus sees an opportunity and strikes a deal with Hero: if he can procure Philia for Hero, he will earn his freedom. This sets in motion a series of comedic events as Pseudolus embarks on his ambitious plan.

  • The Diary of Anne Frank

    Featured Cast

    Young Anne and her family of four hide from Nazi army which occupies Amsterdam during the holocaust. Along with another family and a bachelor, the Franks take shelter with the aid of friends in a hidden attic, living in cramped quarters and constant fear. Based on the real-life diary of Anne Frank.

  • My Brilliant Divorce

    Written by Geraldine Aron

    Directed by Matt McGrath

    Featured Cast

    Polly Draper

    In this brilliantly observed one-woman play, middle-aged Angela attempts to find a new life when husband Max leaves for a younger woman. Using a wonderful mixture of comedy and pathos, she recounts her journey back to happiness.

  • Big Maybelle: Soul of the Blues

    Written by Paul Levine

    Directed by Paul Levine

    Featured Cast

    Lillias White

    Set in a Cleveland, Ohio psychiatric hospital/rehab facility where she spent the last years of her life, Big Maybelle tells the audience the story of her breathtaking rise to world renown against odds almost impossible to believe.

  • The Crucible

    Featured Cast

    Written in the early 1950s, Arthur Miller’s play “The Crucible” takes place in Salem, Massachusetts, during the 1692 Salem witch trials. This was a time when paranoia, hysteria, and deceit gripped the Puritan towns of New England. Miller captured the events in a riveting story that is now considered a modern classic in the theater. He wrote it during the “Red Scare” of the 1950s and used the Salem witch trials as a metaphor for the “witch hunts” of communists in America.

  • To Kill a Mockingbird

    Featured Cast

    Set in Alabama in 1934, Harper Lee’s enduring story of racial injustice and childhood innocence centers on one of the most venerated characters in American literature, small-town lawyer Atticus Finch. He encourages kindness and empathy in his children, Scout and Jem, but is pushed to the limits of these qualities himself when he resolves to uncover the truth in a town that seems determined to hide it.

  • Enter Laughing

    Directed by Stuart Ross

    Featured Cast

    Paul Binotto, Ray DeMattis, Erick Devine, Betsy DiLellio, Jill Eikenberry, Josh Grisetti, Richard Kind, Eric Mann, Gerry McIntyre, Gina Milo, Murphy Davis, Kate Shindle, Emily Shoolin, Michael Tucker

    Loosely based on the life of Carl Reiner, the story takes place in 1938 and focuses on a stage-struck, woman-loving young Jewish boy from New York named David Kolowitz. David works as a delivery boy in a sewing machine factory. His boss, Mr. Foreman wants to train him to take over the business. Meanwhile, David’s domineering parents want him to become a druggist. But David has other ideas; even though he has no experience, he dreams of being an actor. At his friend Marvin’s suggestion, David tries out for a part in a play, and somehow manages to get cast. Although discouraged by his parents and boss, he leaves their dreams and his devoted girlfriend Wanda behind and is soon performing as the leading man in a third-rate theatrical company while being seduced by the resident less-than leading lady, the daughter of the hammy artistic director. In his first performance, everything that can go wrong, does so in hilarious ways.

  • Betty’s Summer Vacation

    Written by Christopher Durang

    Directed by Trip Cullman

    Featured Cast

    John Behlmann, Veanne Cox, Tom Riis Farrell, Jacob Hoffman, Tim Intravata, Celia Keenan-Bolger, Kate O'Phalen, Heidi Schrek, Bobby Steggert

    Betty is looking forward to spending a nice summer relaxing in a rented seaside house. Her plans quickly go awry when Betty realizes she is sharing the house with some disturbed individuals, including a possible serial killer and a man who flashes everyone. To top it off, there are odd voices coming from the ceiling that no one can shut up. A farce on America’s obsession with murder and scandal, Betty’s Summer Vacation is a disturbing yet darkly humorous play.

  • Tru

    Written by Jay Presson Allen

    Directed by Judith Ivey

    Directed by

    Featured Cast

    Darrell Hammond

    It’s December 1975 and Truman Capote is alone in his New York apartment, reeling from a crisis that cost him the elite social circle he adored. Drawn entirely from Capote’s own words, this funny and heartbreaking one-man play is an unflinching portrait of an artist at his breaking point, confronting the consequences of his most scandalous work.

  • The Miracle Worker

    Featured Cast

    Trapped in a secret, silent world, unable to communicate, young Helen Keller is violent and spoiled, treated by her family as subhuman. Only her new teacher, Annie Sullivan, sees a mind and spirit waiting to be rescued from Helen’s dark, tortured silence. After scenes of intense physical and emotional struggle, Helen’s breakthrough finally arrives with the utterance of a single, glorious word: “water.”

  • Romance

    Written by David Mamet

    Directed by Lisa Peterson

    Featured Cast

    Chris Bauer, Darrell Hammond, Richard Kind, Joe Pallister, Reg Rogers, Joey Slotnick

    A courtroom is presided over by The Judge, whose allergy medications make him so drowsy he repeatedly falls asleep. Later, he becomes so manic he eventually ends up stripping in the middle of the court. Meanwhile, The Prosecutor has to deal with his flamboyant and often difficult-to-control boyfriend Bernard, nick-named Bunny. Bunny unexpectedly comes to the court room, “bringing out the inner Queer Guy in the Judge and his Bailiff.[6] The gentile Defense Attorney is swapping racial slurs with his Jewish client, The Defendant. The Defendant suddenly comes up with a brilliant idea to solve all the problems in the Middle East.

  • Fifth of July

    Written by Lanford Wilson

    Directed by Terry Kinney

    Featured Cast

    David Wilson Barnes, Daniel Deferrai, Kally Duling, Elizabeth Franz, Shane MacRae, Anson Mount, Jennifer Mudge, Kellie Overbey

    Ken and Jed are living in Ken’s family home in Lebanon, Missouri, with Ken now having second thoughts about teaching English at the local high school this coming year. Longtime friend Gwen is heiress to a copper conglomerate who hopes to purchase Ken and Jed’s home, convert it into a recording studio, and kickstart a singing career. June is Ken’s unmarried sister, whose thirteen-year-old daughter Shirley may be John’s real motivation for returning to Missouri, the now married man having been one of June’s lovers a baker’s dozen or so years ago. Sally is Ken and June’s aunt, who has been carrying her late husband’s ashes in a candy box for the past year, prompting nephew and niece to suggest that now might be a good time to scatter them. Weston is stoned throughout the weekend. Oh, and there’s going to be someone’s funeral on the Fifth Of July

  • Dissonance

    Written by Damian Lanigan

    Directed by Lonnie Price

    Featured Cast

    Rosie Benton, Daniel Gerroll, Morgan Spector, Robert Stanton, Gregory Wooddell

    Focused on the Bradley String Quartet, created and overseen by the abrasive and tyrannical James Bradley. Beth, the cellist, has been approached by a rock superstar who has offered her, at a huge salary, an opportunity to teach him classical music, with the idea of incorporating it into his next album.

    Jonny, the rock star, sweetly and winningly played by Gregory Wooddell, is a gentle soul, and not at all the archetype of a degenerate, drug-soaked, self absorbed pop celebrity, despite the gargantuan self portrait that dominates, like a rumpled guru, his Tribeca apartment.

    He has depth, compassion and an honest desire to learn the music he has so far avoided in his gigantically successful life. Mr. Wooddell strikes all of these notes and more, and makes of Jonny a sympathetic and lovable person and—as it happens—a catalyst to uncover the many dissonances both between and within the members of the string quartet.

    2000s

  • Dinner

    Written by Moira Buffini

    Directed by David Esbjornson

    Featured Cast

    Reed Birney, Laura Campbell, Daniel Gerroll, Brian Hutchison, Mercedes Ruehl, J Smith-Cameron, Eric Walton

    A darkly satirical comedy about a high-society dinner party that descends into chaos. Hostess Paige throws a lavish yet twisted celebration for her husband Lars, a modern-day philosopher, serving a grotesque meal designed to humiliate him and unsettle their pretentious guests. As the night unfolds, with topics like murder, truth, and suicide on the menu, civility breaks down and egos are ruthlessly skewered.

  • The Diary of Anne Frank

    Featured Cast

    Young Anne and her family of four hide from Nazi army which occupies Amsterdam during the holocaust. Along with another family and a bachelor, the Franks take shelter with the aid of friends in a hidden attic, living in cramped quarters and constant fear. Based on the real-life diary of Anne Frank.

  • Dames at Sea

    Directed by Ray Roderick

    Featured Cast

    Xavier Cano, Joyce Chittick, Stuart Marland, Kristen Martin, Laurie Wells, Patrick Wetzel

    When talented young hopeful Ruby arrives in New York City with nothing but a pair of tap shoes in her suitcase, she is determined to break into show business. She stumbles into the cast of troubled show “Dames at Sea”, in which broke and pessimistic producer Hennesey is terrorized by Mona Kent, the aggressive, seductive, and surprisingly shady leading lady. Ruby seems to be in luck, as she makes a friend in clever chorus girl Joan, and falls in love with Dick, a singing sailor with songwriting ambitions, who just happens to be from her own hometown of Centerville, Utah. But things take a turn for the worse when Mona sets her sights — and her claws — on Dick, and Hennesey loses the theatre, which is promptly bulldozed out from under the cast and crew. Can Dick and his pal Lucky save the show by producing it on their battleship? Will the reluctant Captain be persuaded by Mona Kent, who just happens to be his tropical fling from long ago? Will Ruby go out there a chorus girl, but come back a star?

  • Bell, Book and Candle

    Written by John Van Druten

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Arija Bareikis, Jarlath Comroy, Matt McGrath, Gordana Rashovich, Sam Robards

    This light hearted 50’s comedy is about what happens when a witch in New York makes a lover of a very conventional man and then has to face the consequences when she really falls in love with him. Gillian Holroyd becomes interested in her upstairs neighbor and tenant and hexes him into falling in love with her. Shep Henderson, her quarry, is mystified, delighted and completely unaware that other worldly forces are at work. Despite the oddness of Gillian’s aunt and brother, themselves an endearingly addled old witch and a fun-loving warlock, Shep is oblivious. He only knows that his life changed when he crossed over Gillian’s threshold. When she realizes that she is falling in love herself, Gillian faces a dilemma: she will lose her considerable powers if she acts on her feelings. Will love prevail?

  • Shanghai Moon

    Written by Charles Busch

    Directed by Carl Andres

    Featured Cast

    Charles Busch, Jarlath Conroy, Julie Halston, Jopdi Lin, Gordana Rashovich, Thom Sesma

    Shanghai, 1931. Lady Sylvia Allington is the beautiful, young American-born wife of an aged British diplomat. She and her husband travel to Shanghai to persuade a notorious Chinese warlord, General Gong Fei, to donate a priceless antique jade bust to the British Museum. Lady Sylvia, a former carnival cooch dancer from Chicago, falls headlong into a fatal love affair with the mysterious Gong Fei, getting hooked on opium and antagonizing the general’s chief adviser, the elderly Doctor Wu, and his enigmatic mistress, Mah Li. A scandal involving a local bordello madame, Mrs. Carroll, and a cockney drug runner named Pug Talbot leads to tragedy.

  • Ain’t Misbehavin’

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    James Alexander, Monica Patton, Q Smith, Jim Weaver, Aurelia Williams

    The Harlem Renaissance of the 1920s and 1930s comes to life in the three-time Tony award-winning musical revue, Ain’t Misbehavin’. Join five performers on a journey through the timeless music of Thomas “Fats” Waller. You’ll be jumpin’ and jivin’ with memorable songs such as “Honeysuckle Rose”, “Ain’t Misbehavin’”, “Black and Blue”, “This Joint is Jumpin’ ” and “I’ve Got a Feeling I’m Falling.”

  • Beyond Therapy

    Written by Christopher Durang

    Directed by Alex Timmers

    Featured Cast

    Kate Burton, Katie Finneran, Darren Goldstein, Darrell Hammond, Matt McGrath, Bryce Pinkham

    Prudence and Bruce are two Manhattanites looking for love, stability, and sanity. On the advice of his therapist, Bruce places a personal ad in the newspaper; on the advice of her therapist, Prudence answers it. At first, it seems as though the two couldn’t be less suited to each other: Prudence is a perfectionist, cautious and closed off from the world, while Bruce, who lives with his jealous lover, Bob, is emotional and spontaneous. But fate (and their therapists) continue to bring the two together. Much to their surprise, Prudence and Bruce find they might actually like each other. Can they survive neuroses, jealousy, and their crazy therapists?

  • Things Being What They Are

    Written by Wendy MacLeod

    Directed by Leonard Foglia

    Featured Cast

    Brian D'Arcy James, Tom McGowan

    As Bill anxiously waits for his unfaithful wife and his furniture, he is visited by Jack, a divorced neighbor who suggests the loneliness of life after marriage. At first Jack appears to be a sitcom character—intrusive, needy, boorish—but gradually Bill’s perception of his new “friend” deepens. While it’s true that Jack managed to lose his wife’s trust and his children’s love, Bill discovers that Jack is wrestling with circumstances that would challenge the best of us. A funny and wistful exploration of love, loss, masculinity, and the needs that bring people together and drive them apart.

  • The Lady in Question

    Written by Charles Busch

    Directed by Christopher Ashley

    Featured Cast

    Candy Buckley, Charles Busch, Barrett Foa, Julie Halston, Larry Keith, Richard Kind, Matt McGrath, Perry Ojeda, Ana Reeder

    A freewheeling satire of patriotic 1940’s thrillers like Notorious and Escape, The Lady in Question tells the suspenseful tale of Gertrude Garnet, the most glamorous concert pianist on the international stage. When Gertrude tours Bavaria in 1940, a handsome American professor challenges her colossal self-absorption by engaging her aid in rescuing his mother from a Nazi prison.

  • Turandot: The Rumble for the Ring

    Written by Diane Paulus

    Directed by Diane Paulus

    Featured Cast

    Uzo Aduba, Matthew Scott Campbell, Ryan Dunn, Manoel Feliciano, Billy Kuehnle, Michael Lanning, Bryce Ryness, Don Stephenson, Teal Wicks, Ray Wills

    A fresh and dynamic new musical based on the story of Turandot, jam-packed with some of the greatest arias from other operas… only this time they are set to a beat that will keep you rockin’.

  • The Night Season

    Written by Rebecca Lenkiewicz

    Directed by Lonny Price

    Featured Cast

    Rosie Benton, Katherine Helmond, David Patrick Kelly, Michael O'Keefe, Kellie Overbey, Richard Short

    Late at night, shoeless, in the rain, a film actor playing he poet Yeats turns up drunk at his appointed Sligo digs He is met by the grandmother and they dance together to ‘Lili Marlene’ In the morning they are discovered, sharing a blanket, by Patrick and his three daughters Patrick craves tobacco, whiskey and a date with the local barmaid; the sisters yearn for sensation and escape.

  • Quartet

    Written by Ronald Harwood

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Kaye Ballard, Paul Hecht, Simon Jones, Sian Phillips

    Cecily, Reggie and Wilfred reside in a home for retired opera singers in Kent, England. Each year, on the tenth of October, there is a concert to celebrate Verdi’s birthday. Jean, who used to be married to Reggie, arrives at the home and disrupts their equilibrium. She still acts like a diva and refuses to sing. But the show must go on in this funny and poignant play.

  • Darwin in Malibu

    Written by Crispin Whitell

    Directed by Daniel Gerroll

    Featured Cast

    Anna Chlumsky, Richard Easton, Neal Huff, Hal Linden

    Malibu, California. The present. One hundred and twenty years after his death, Charles Darwin is hanging out in a beach house overlooking the Pacific with a girl young enough to be his daughter. His peace is rudely disturbed when his old friend Thomas Huxley washes up on the beach closely followed by the Bishop of Oxford. And Darwin suddenly finds himself entangled in an enthralling and thought-provoking comedy about God, science and plastic surgery.

  • Viva La Vida

    Written by Diane Shaffer

    Directed by Susan Tubert

    Featured Cast

    Jaime Robert Carrillo, Liza Colon-Zayas, Andres De La Fuente, Chuck Novatka, Rene Pereyra, Mercedes Ruehl

    Set in the last year or so of Kahlo’s life; she is in a body cast and attended by a nurse, Rosita. She has a painting in the Louvre, Kahlo reminds Rosita, and Diego does not, yet she is known mostly as Diego’s wife. In her 1954 obituary in The New York Time, the second paragraph begins, “She also was a painter.”

  • The Who’s Tommy

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Ashley Bachner, Philip Michael Baskerville, Brian Beach, Paul Binotto, Shelby Braxton-Brooks, Gavin Esham, Nikka Graff Lanzarone, Mike McGowan, Euan Morton, Liz Pearce, Josh Walden, Laura Woyasz

    After witnessing the murder of his mother’s lover by his father, Tommy is traumatized into a catatonic state. As young Tommy floats through life in post World War II England, he suffers abuse from sadistic relatives and neighbors. In his adolescence, Tommy discovers a talent for playing pinball and is catapulted into stardom. When his mother, Mrs. Walker is finally able to break his catatonic state, Tommy is transformed into an international pinball superstar, inspiring youth around the world. The Who’s Tommy is a 5-time Tony Award-winning musical.

  • Japes

    Written by Simon Gray

    Directed by Maria Aitken

    Featured Cast

    Francesca Faridany, Matt McGrath, Sam Robards

    When Michael, a student with literary ambitions, brings his new girlfriend Anita back to the North London family home he shares with his younger brother Jason, a love triangle is formed which, over the next twenty years, will have an incalculable impact on each of their lives. One of Simon Gray’s finest plays, Japes is a unique depiction of love and brotherhood.

  • Pippin

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Anastasia Barzee, Larry Keith, Sebastian La Cause, David Larsen, Alice Playten, Stephanie Pope-Caffey, Raphael Odell Shapiro, B. D. Wong

    As told by a traveling troupe of actors led by the cunning and charming Leading Player, Pippin is the story of a young prince, heir to the throne, who is searching for his own “corner of the sky.” Pippin returns from university certain that he will find a fulfilling purpose in life. As encouraged by the Leading Player, Pippin dabbles in bloody battle, licentious and lusty sexual entanglements, and savvy political maneuvers, only to discover that true happiness is more complicated than he thought.

  • Sleuth

    Written by Anthony Shaffer

    Directed by Will Frears

    Featured Cast

    Derek Cecil, Tony Roberts

    The ultimate game of cat and mouse is played out in a cozy English country house owned by celebrated mystery writer, Andrew Wyke. Invited guest Milo Tindle, a young rival who shares Wyke’s love for games, declares his intention to run off with Wyke’s wife. The two men devise an elaborate revenge/power game; through their style and cunning, the stakes continue to rise, leading to the play’s inexorable, heart-stopping finish.

  • No Time for Comedy

    Written by S. N. Behrman

    Directed by Daniel Gerroll

    Featured Cast

    Mark Blum, Daniel Gerroll, Edward Hibbert, Sharon Lawrence, Gabriel Nassbaum, Grammy Singer

    A seven-year itch induced largely by a writer’s block infects playwright Gaylord Esterbrook. In the presence, if not precisely the arms, of “the other woman,” Amanda, Gaylord’s writing problem seems dispelled. Moreover, instead of permitting him to write trivial comedies, where he displays unquestioned mastery, Amanda inspires Gaylord to write a profound drama. “Rot,” thinks actress-wife Linda Esterbrook, somewhat out of practical concern as she awaits the fourth of her husband’s comedies as her next triumphant vehicle. (Her tolerance had already forgiven him his assumed infidelity.) Better to write successful trivial comedies than shallow tragedies. Why not a comedy based on their own romantic triangle at a time when the world is precariously perched on total chaos, and her husband, masking his need for “experience” with a kind of altruism, wants to run off to join the Spanish insurgents? What better time for comedy than a period when “The more inhuman the rest of the world the more human we. The grosser and more cruel the others, the more scrupulous, the more fastidious, the more precisely just and delicate we.” Her justification? “One should keep in one’s own mind a little clearing in the jungle of life. One must laugh.” Gaylord recognizes the wisdom of his wife’s reasoning and prepares to write his latest comedy based on his experience with Amanda.

  • Limonade Tous Les Jours

    Written by Charles L. Mee

    Directed by Zoe Caldwell

    Featured Cast

    Alan Alda, Eric Bondoc, Nicole Leach

    Jacqueline is a young Parisian cabaret singer; Andrew is an American in his 50s, both of them recovering from recent ruined love relationships. When they meet at a Paris cafe and then, without quite meaning to, spend the day wandering through the city together, they speak of all the reasons why they shouldn’t fall in love. And so: they do.

  • Once on This Island

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Carey Brown, Dylan Collins, Kevin Dorsey, Monique Midgette, Kenita Miller, Christopher Morgan, Soara Joye Ross, Josh Tower, Raven Turner, Dathan Williams

    An island of storytellers come together to tell a story of love, bravery, and strength…the story of the peasant girl, Ti Moune. An orphan, chosen by the Gods, is taken into a simple and loving family, Though content, she feels like she was destined for something more. After a terrible accident caused by a wicked storm, Ti Moune falls for a handsome, ailing, stranger whom she tries desperately to nurse back to health. She bargains with the Gods for his life, but to do so she must make the ultimate sacrifice. This sets our young peasant girl on the ultimate quest to answer the age old question, can love conquer death?

  • Auntie Mame

    Written by Jerome Lawrence

    Directed by Richard Sabellico

    Featured Cast

    Tolan Aman, Kerrie Blaisdell, Charles Busch, Penny Fuller, Jennifer Harmon, Michael McCormick, Susan Pourfar, Gordana Rashovich, Victor Slezak, Patrick Ryan Sullivan

    In October of 1928, the newly orphaned Patrick is sent from Chicago to live with his Auntie Mame in New York City. Only 10 years old, Patrick finds himself in the zany world of Mame Dennis, an eccentric socialite determined to live life to the fullest. From a progressive “clothing discouraged” school to mastering a perfect gin martini, Patrick soon adapts to Auntie Mame’s antics, much to the dismay of his trustee, Dwight Babcock, a humorless man dedicated to conservative principles – the opposite of what Auntie Mame represents. Patrick is taken away and the stock market crashes, leaving Mame scrambling to survive, whether as an actress, an operator, or a department store saleswoman. Throw in a Southern gentleman, an actress pretending to be English, and a sheltered secretary finally learning to live, and Auntie Mame’s world is anything but dull. Through all of her adventures, Mame’s true loyalty lies with Patrick, and his with her – and together, they remind everyone that “Life is a banquet, and most poor sons-of-bitches are starving to death!”

  • Rough Crossing

    Written by Tom Stoppard

    Directed by Daniel Gerrolll

    Featured Cast

    Dylan Baker, Christine Ebersole, Edward Hibbert, Richard Kind, Gabriel Olds, Tony Roberts

    The co-authors, the composer and most of the cast of a comedy destined for Broadway are simultaneously trying to finish and rehearse the play while crossing the Atlantic on an ocean liner.

  • A Christmas Carol

    Written by Chris Schario

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Noah Bean, Jason Blaine, Gretchen Cleevely, Jonathan Freeman, Jennifer Harmon, Wynn Harmon, Susan Mitchell

    On Christmas Eve, Scrooge is visited by a series of ghosts, starting with his old business partner, Jacob Marley. The three spirits which follow, the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Christmas Present and Christmas Yet to Come, show Scrooge how his mean behaviour has affected those around him. At the end of the story he is relieved to discover that there is still time for him to change and we see him transformed into a generous and kind-hearted human being.

  • The Boyfriend

    Directed by Julie Andrews

    Featured Cast

    Justin Bohan, Andrea Chamberlain, Joyce Chittick, Veanne Cox, Rick Faugno, Jenny Fellner, Delphi Harrington, Nancy Hess, Byron Jennings, Sean Palmer, Meredith Patterson, Mark Price, Annie Ramsay, Tony Roberts, Wayne Wilcox

    It’s Carnival time on the French Riviera, and the “perfect young ladies” of Madame Dubonnet’s Finishing School are all aflutter with excitement at the opportunity to dress in beautiful frocks, dance the Charleston, and acquire that most prized of possessions — a Boy Friend. Sweet young heiress Polly Browne, whose stern father forbids her to encourage men out of fear that they are after her money, is embarrassed to admit her lack of suitors to her friends, and must hide her shame by sending herself love notes. Enter Tony, a kind, romantic, handsome — messenger boy! It is love at first sight for the darling duo, and Polly, pretending to be Madame Dubonnet’s secretary, enjoys for the first time a romance of equals. Confusion arises when Polly’s father, Percival Browne, arrives in Nice, only to discover in Madame Dubonnet a former flame, and rich old Lord and Lady Brockhurst appear in pursuit of Tony, leading everyone to assume he must be a thief.

  • Earth to Bucky

    Written by Jack Heifner

    Directed by Thomas Caruso

    Featured Cast

    Matt Keeslar, T. R. Knight, Kellie Overbey Shane

    Two brothers, one woman, and the ways we change each other. An irreverent comedy filled with insights about love, life, death and the family ties that bind us together. Into the quiet, small town life of two brothers enters a grieving woman who is simultaneously trying to bury her Mama and ignite an old flame. Throughout events both uproariously funny and poignantly powerful, decisions are made that change the direction of the characters’ lives forever.

  • The Lover / Bacchanalia

    Written by Harold Pinter

    Directed by Daniel Gerrolll

    Featured Cast

    John Beuscher, John Glover, Sally Murphy, Ted Schneider

    The Lover: The Lover is a quirky, tense, intriguing one-act by Harold Pinter that examines the private intricacies of modern marriage. To all outward appearances, Sarah and Richard are a respectable, conventional suburban couple. Behind closed doors, however, the couple enjoys a surprising and intriguing arrangement: every day, while Richard is at work, Sarah’s lover comes to the house. Richard, meanwhile, frequents a prostitute in the city. Yet, the two speak openly to one another of their extramarital affairs without jealousy, judgement, or anger. As we learn more about Sarah and Richard’s affairs, we see how a modern married couple has found an unconventional way to cope with extramarital temptation.

    Bacchanalia: A happy but nervous couple waiting at a railroad station cafe in Salzburg for the arrival of the woman’s husband, Felix Staufner, a great playwright. They plan to tell him about their affair, like civilized people, then run away together, far away. But when Felix (Victor Slezak) arrives, things don’t go as planned.

  • Nobody Don’t Like Yogi

    Written by Thomas Lysaught

    Directed by Paul Limke

    Featured Cast

    Ben Gazzara

    Set in the clubhouse of the cathedral of baseball, this one-man play recreates the day in 1999 when Yogi Berra returned to Yankee stadium after a 14-year absence to throw the opening pitch – and shows why Yogi Berra is a national treasure and a New York icon.

  • Talley’s Folly

    Written by Lanford Wilson

    Directed by Ron Lagomarsino

    Featured Cast

    Matthew Arkin, Jessica Hecht

    The time is 1944, and the place is the ornate, deserted Victorian boathouse on the Talley property in Lebanon, MO. Matt Friedman, an accountant from St. Louis, has arrived to plead his love to Sally Talley, the susceptible but uncertain daughter of the family. Bookish, erudite, totally honest and delightfully funny, Sally rebuffs him, but Matt refuses to accept her rebuffs and fears that her family would never approve of their marriage. Charming and indomitable, he gradually overcomes her defenses, telling his innermost secrets to his loved one and in return, learning hers as well. Gradually he awakens Sally to the possibilities of a life together until, in the final, touching moments of the Pulitzer Prize-winning play, it is clear that they are two kindred spirits who have truly found each other – two “lame ducks” who, in their union, will find a wholeness rare in human relationships.

  • West End Horror

    Written by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Anthony Dodge, Wynn Harmon, Martin Hiller, Matt Kovich, Matt Loney, Terrance Mann, Dennis Ryan, Mark Shanahan

    In Victorian London amidst a series of theater-related murders. Theater critic Jonathan McCarthy is found dead, and chaos ensues with a missing police surgeon and more murders. Sherlock Holmes steps in to unravel the tangled web of crime filled with real-life literary figures.

  • Blithe Spirit

    Written by Noel Coward

    Directed by Daniel Gerroll

    Featured Cast

    Kerrie Blaisdell, Herb Foster, Daniel Gerroll, Dana Ivey, Patricia Calember, Twiggy Lawson, Angela Thorton

    Set at the house of writer Charles Condomine, and his wife, Ruth. One evening, Charles invites local eccentric medium, Madame Arcati, to hold a seance at his house. He asks along his friends, Dr. and Mrs. Bradman, intending to gather character inspiration from Madame Arcati for his latest book. Despite initially thinking the seance has been a failure, it soon becomes clear that Madame Arcati has unwittingly brought back Charles’ first wife, Elvira, to haunt him. Once in his house, Elvira is unable to leave and, as she cannot be seen or heard by Ruth, she causes all kinds of mischievous trouble between the married couple. When Elvira unwittingly causes Ruth’s death in her attempts to bring Charles over to be with her, Charles becomes haunted by both of his now-deceased wives. Frustrated by their odd situation, the threesome call on Madame Arcati once more to send Elvira and Ruth back to the other side.

  • Our Town

    Written by Thornton Wilder

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Mark Baker, Noah Bean, Reg E. Cathey, Michael Downey, John Fiedler, Catherine Gaffigan, Sophie Hayden, Bryan Hicks, Pat Hingle, Bryce Dallas Howard, Adriane Lenox, B.D. Wong, Frank Wood

    Centered around Grover’s Corners, New Hampshire, a small town representing all of human life in its simplicity and profoundness. The Pulitzer Prize-winning work has remained a classic for decades, unfolding in three acts, capturing ordinary moments that shape existence, and highlighting themes of life, love, and death. Through ordinary characters, the audience witnesses the beauty of everyday experiences.

  • Jar the Floor

    Written by Cheryl L. West

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Kerrie Blaisdell, Adrienne Carter, Paula Newsome, Claudia Robinson, Gammy Singer

    A quartet of black women spanning four generations makes up this heartwarming dramatic comedy. The four, plus the white woman friend of the youngest, come together to celebrate the matriarch’s ninetieth birthday. It’s a wild party, one that is a lovable lunatic glance at the exhilarating challenge of growing old amidst the exasperating trials of growing up.

  • Seascape

    Written by Edward Albee

    Directed by Leonard Foglia

    Featured Cast

    Richie Coster, Susan Floyd, Josef Sommer, Maria Tucci

    On a deserted stretch of beach a middle-aged couple, relaxing after a picnic lunch, talk idly about home, family and their life together. She sketches, he naps, and then, suddenly, they are joined by two sea creatures—lizards who have decided to leave the ocean depths and come ashore. Initial fear, and then suspicion of each other, are soon replaced by curiosity and, before long, the humans and the lizards (who speak admirable English) are engaged in a fascinating dialogue. The lizards, who are at a very advanced stage of evolution, are contemplating the terrifying, yet exciting, possibility of embarking on life out of the water; and the couple, for whom existence has grown flat and routine, holds the answers to their most urgent questions. These answers are given with warmth, humor and poetic eloquence, and with emotional and intellectual reverberations that will linger in the heart and mind long after the play has ended.

  • Accomplice

    Written by Ruppert Holmes

    Directed by Daniel Gerroll

    Featured Cast

    Joelle Carter, David Chandler, Daniel Gerroll, Patricia Kalember

    The story begins in Dartmoor, England at the stylish weekend retreat of the affluent Derek and Janet Taylor, and both adultery and murder are in the air. But we will soon learn that all is never as it seems in this electrifying game of trickery and misdirection. Who is the hunter and who the hunted… and precisely who is the title character of Accomplice?

  • Hair

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Jennifer Blake, Tom Deckman, Carmen R. Floyd, Alan H. Green, Jamie Kirchner, Douglas Kreeger, Liza Lapira, Todd Lawson, Sherelle Lindsey, Jeremiah Lockwood Miller, Rashad Naylor, Kate Reinders, Amanda Serkasevich, Brent Vance, Max Von Essen, Matt Walton

    The American Tribal Love-Rock Musical follows a young group of hippies fighting the establishment, dodging the drafts, getting high, living and loving in New York City. It’s 1967: the Vietnam War raging and the Age of Aquarius is dawning. Claude, his best friend Berger, their roommate Sheila, and their Tribe of friends struggle to balance the demands of the harsh and violent world with their dream for a more beautiful and peaceful world. When Claude receives his draft notice, he must decide whether to join his friends in resisting the draft, or bow to the pressures of society and his conservative parents, thereby sacrificing his ideals and, possibly, his life.

  • Gross Points

    Written by Ira Lewis

    Directed by Stephen Hamilton

    Featured Cast

    Aria Alperty, Alec Baldwin, Richie Coster, James MacCaffrey, Jack Ryland, Chip Zien

    Johnny Checco perceives himself as a superstar of the screen whose soul belongs to the art of the stage in a spoof of America’s idea of royalty found in the entertainment industry.

  • The Woman in Black

    Directed by Leonard Foglia

    Featured Cast

    Alicia Brockwell, Jason Butler Harner, Josef Sommer

    A lawyer hires an actor to tutor him in recounting to family and friends a story that has long troubled him concerning events that transpired when he attended the funeral of an elderly recluse. There he caught sight of the woman in black, the mere mention of whom terrifies the locals, for she is a specter who haunts the neighborhood where her illegitimate child was accidentally killed. Anyone who sees her dies! The lawyer has invited some friends to watch as he and the actor recreate the events of that dark and stormy night.

  • Hedda Gabler

    Written by Henrik Ibsen

    Directed by Nicholas Martin

    Featured Cast

    Kate Burton, Katie Finneran, Michael Emerson, David Lansbury, Angela Thornton, Harris Yulin

    Bored and restricted by her middle-class environment, Hedda plays out her own fantasies and psychological games with those nearest to her to an ultimately costly end. The play opens as Hedda and her academic husband, Georges Tesman, return from honeymoon and immediately it is clear that Hedda is neither happy nor satisfied in her new role as Tesman’s wife. She is, however, pregnant. Soon after their return, Hedda is reacquainted with an old school friend, Mrs. Elvsted, and the brilliant but wayward writer Eilert Loevborg. It becomes clear that Hedda has personal history with Loevborg and it is at this point that her machinations begin. Hedda finds pleasure in manipulating Loevborg into drinking again and thus ruining both his career and his relationship with Mrs. Elvsted. Ultimately she persuades the conflicted writer to take his own life. However, Hedda finds herself under the control of their imposing friend, Judge Brack, who makes it clear that he knows she gave Loevborg the gun.

  • Love Janis

    Written by Randy Myler

    Directed by Randy Myler

    Featured Cast

    John Beuscher, Catherine Curtin, Andra Mitrovich, Cathy Richardson

    A musical stage show about the life and music of rock and roll singer Janis Joplin, whose feelings are expressed through the use of Janis’s own words shared by three separate “Janises” who embody the masks the musician wore.

  • You Can’t Take It With You

    Written by George Kaufman

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Mason Adams, Roger Bart, Joan Copeland, Shelley Delaney, John Fielder, Jonathan Freeman, Penny Fuller, Bryan Hicks, Larry Keith, Jennifer Dundas, Talmadge Lowe, Peter Maloney, Roz Ryan, Mary Testa

    Grandpa Vanderhof and his wacky family, the Sycamores, have been happily living their zany lives in his house by Columbia University in New York for many years. This family (and their friends) are a madcap group of eccentrics, marching to the beat of their own drum, with pride and joy. Their hobbies include collecting snakes, building fireworks in the basement, writing a myriad of plays that never get published, and taking ballet lessons. Things like stress, jobs, and paying taxes to the government are for other people, not for them! But, when practical young Alice Sycamore becomes engaged to her company’s Vice President Tony Kirby, the Vanderhof/Sycamore clan must straighten up to meet the new in-laws. Disaster ensues when the Kirbys arrive at the wrong time and, despite the best laid plans, see Alice’s family in all of its crazy glory. The evening ends with everyone in the house getting arrested, and Alice ending the engagement. It isn’t until Grandpa’s wise speech to Mr. Kirby about the importance of living life to the fullest that the two families find a way to accept each other, and love conquers all.

    1990s

  • Tinka’s New Dress

    Featured Cast

    Marionette theatre play based on the illegal underground “Daisy” plays of Nazi-occupied Czechoslovakia, with a cast of 30 characters.

  • Something in the Air

    Written by Richard Dresser

    Directed by Melia Bensussen

    Featured Cast

    Mark Blum, Jude Ciccolella, Anne O'Sullivan, Steven Weber, Janet Zarish

    A desperate man discovers the last sure-fire investment left on earth. A contemporary film noir, the play takes place in a nameless American city where Walker has hit rock bottom. He encounters a shadowy power broker, Neville, who sets him up with a can’t-miss financial opportunity which somehow misses. Walker is torn between the dark forces that have trapped him and a fragile love affair that just might be enough to save him.

  • The Factory Girls

    Written by Frank McGuinness

    Directed by Nye Heron

    Featured Cast

    Malcolm Adams, Kate Burton, Gretchen Cleevely, Christopher McHale, Bernadette Quigley, Rebecca Schull, Celia Weston

    The story of five women facing the threat of redundancy, who stage a lock-in in a shirt factory in Co. Donegal. As their protest continues the women learn more about each other and themselves as they explore their anger, courage and compassion.

  • Fit to Print: Remotely Controlled

    Directed by Marcia Milgrom Dodge

    Featured Cast

    Roger Bart, Joanna Glushak, Randy Graff, Dennis Ryan, Robert Sella

    A series of comedic sketches meant to mimic and satirize an evening flipping through television channels out of convenience rather than deliberate engagement.

  • Elsa Edgar

    Directed by Murphy Davis

    Featured Cast

    Bob Kingdom

    High above the glamorous skyline of 50’s Manhattan, the terrifying Elsa Maxwell – party hostess and social power broker – drags up for her next masquerade, while J Edgar Hoover, head of the FBI, checks his files, tightens his grip and slips into something a little more comfortable.

    My dear, she knew everybody; Coward and Porter, the Rainers and the Windsors. Making a career out of her legendary ugliness, she dished the dirt on King Farouk, fixed up the Aly Khan with Rita Hayworth… and the only love of her own life, Maria Callas. If you were on Elsa’s list, your entry into High Society was assured; once on the blacklist, you were persona non grata to all who followed the social sun.

    Elsa’s world of masquerade and scandal had a shadow; J Edgar Hoover, eavesdropper, McCarthyite, part-time transvestite and control freak. The FBI was also compiling lists, spreading gossip, dividing the world into the acceptable and the unacceptable.

  • A Coffin in Egypt

    Written by Horton Foote

    Directed by Leonard Foglia

    Featured Cast

    Glynis Johns, Mindy H. Washington, Eve Montgomery

    Myrtle Bledsoe, a ninety-year-old Texas widow, looks back on the dramatic events that caused a small Southern town, and her own relationships, incredible strife. This almost-monologue by American master Horton Foote is a haunting tale of how men and women, blacks and whites, rich and poor are all entangled in the chaos of life.

  • Noel & Gertie

    Directed by Leigh Lawson

    Featured Cast

    Twiggy, James Warwick

    The tale of the friendship between two of the 20th century’s greatest stage personalities: Gertrude Lawrence and Noël Coward. Although they only appeared in two productions together, Private Lives and Tonight at 8:30, they epitomized an era of style and elegance. The songs, sketches and snippets of scenes pieced together here have the entrancing effect of accurately portraying this remarkable duo and the era they helped to define.

  • House

    Written by Jon Robin Baitz

    Directed by Joe Mantello

    Featured Cast

    Richard Dreyfuss, Marsha Mason, Rue McClanahan, Debra Monk, Daniel Stern
  • Make Someone Happy

    Directed by Phyllis Newman

    Featured Cast

    Jim Bracchitta, Melissa Errico, Adam Grupper, Dee Hoty, Paula Newsome, Max Perlman
  • My Good Name

    Written by Arthur Laurents

    Directed by David Saint

    Featured Cast

    Steve Bassett, Lynn Cohen, Gerrit Graham, Tyrone Mitchell Henderson, Lizbeth Mackay, Eden Riegel, Brooke Smith
  • Heaven & Earth

    Written by Joe Pintauro

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Olivia Birkelund, Fred Burrell, Talmadge Lowe, Roger Robinson, Sloane Shelton, John Wojda

    Based on the book by Steve Wick, the vanishing community of farmers who once were the majority of Long Island struggle to keep the land and lives held by their forebears. Set on the North Fork among the intermixing and colliding waves of English, Irish and Polish settlers and filled with family drama, Heaven and Earth fundamentally asks: What have we done to interfere with the relationship of man and the earth?

  • Virgil Is Still the Frogboy

    Written by Lanford Wilson

    Directed by Marshall Mason

    Featured Cast

    Arija Bareikis, Bobby Cannavale, Jennifer Dundas, Thomas McCarthy, Josh Pais

    Schuyler Browne and his friends, Josh, Ann and Mary, gather for the spring at Schuyler’s family’s Hampton home. Schuyler, a trust-fund kid from wealthy lineage, doesn’t yet know what to do with his life. Josh, very into computers, is on the verge of making millions on a stock market deal done over the Internet. Ann, a would-be dancer, is turned down for a grant and is fearful of becoming a blue collar worker. Mary is a business manager about to open her own company, and the one to open the group to a new member, Chuck, a local carpenter working for her. As the spring passes, the friends begin to clash as all their problems and futures grow. Growing more neurotic, Ann spends her time cooking even as she continues her work in a nearby shop. Tempers fly when Schuyler insults Chuck, and Mary and Josh in turn chide Schuyler for being a snob. More time passes, and Josh, with some of his new money, makes a large contribution to the director of a dance troupe hoping Ann can have a featured role, but his kindness backfires when she is fired on opening night. Schuyler’s feud with Chuck fizzles, but Schuyler’s father informs them all they may no longer live in the house since, come September, he has rented it out. When the time comes to leave, the friends vow to hang onto their meager livings and to their family of friends, but no one really knows how.

  • Noel Coward in Two Keys

    Directed by Tony Walton

    Directed by

    Featured Cast

    Bobby Cannavale, Dee Hoty, Leigh Lawson, Bebe Neuwirth

    Two works by Noel Coward

    Come Into the Garden, Maud: A view of the haute monde, tempered by having the man and wife beAmericans this time. She is a social climber, while he is a rich cornhusker who couldn’t care less about society. While the wife is entertaining a high and mighty prince downstairs, the husband is entertaining a threadbare princess upstairs. It doesn’t take long for the husband to realize he has more in common with royalty than his wife does.

    A Song at Twilight: One of Coward’s late plays, A Song at Twilight is a full-length play about a famous elderly writer, reputedly based on Somerset Maugham, who faces blackmail at the hands of an ex-lover threatening to expose his secret past.

  • Tropeano Paints

    Written by Bill Bozzone

    Directed by Mark Brokaw

    Featured Cast

    Donald Berman, Julie Boyd, Rita Gardner, William Francis McGuire, Kathleen McNenny, Anne O'Sullivan, Michael Rispoli

    A community theater prepares a production of “A Streetcar Named Desire” in an effort to get two of their own back together. The titular Pete Tropeano, a house painter is cast as Mitch, while Dottie, a flaky domestic worker and an amateur actress, who ran out on him, is Stella.

  • A Life in the Theatre

    Written by David Mamet

    Directed by Robert Kalfin

    Featured Cast

    Reese Madigan, Larry Pine

    The audience is taken into the lives of two actors: John, young and rising into the first flush of his success; the other Robert, older, anxious, and beginning to wane. In a series of short, spare, and increasingly raw exchanges, we see the estrangement of youth from age and the wider, inevitable and endless cycle of life, in and out of the theatre.

  • Splendora

    Directed by Jack Hofsiss

    Featured Cast

    Evelyn Baron, Joan Copeland, Nancy Johnston, Ken Krugman, Michael Christopher Moore, Kathy Robinson, Susan Rush, KT Sullivan

    The favorite pastime in Splendora, a small East Texas town, is gossip. People were still talking about outcast Timothy John Coldridge—who ran away fifteen years ago and was never heard from again—until Miss Jessica Gatewood came to town. The exotic and beautiful Miss Jessie, a lady of Victorian bearing and lofty literary ideals, was hired to run the county bookmobile. As if she wasn’t enough to talk about on her own, she moved into the very house in which Timothy John once lived with his grandmother. Miss Jessie’s refined ways and charismatic civic pride captivates the entire town, particularly Brother Leggett, but leaves Sue Ella Lightfoot slightly suspicious. When Miss Jessie and Leggett begin working together on the courthouse restoration project, inspiring others to make Splendora a better place to live, Sue Ella begins to figure out Jessie’s secret. Paying a visit to the town’s newest, most popular citizen, Sue Ella tells her that she knows Miss Jessica Gatewood is really Timothy John Coldridge, but Sue Ella vows she’ll keep the secret. Miss Jessie, thankful, confides that she’s fallen in love with Leggett and is assured that Sue Ella understands. Feeling confident, the Timothy John side of Miss Jessie becomes more forceful, almost careless. At a fund raising event, Jessie is crowned Miss Crepe Myrtle, and stunned, is asked to name her Cavalier—Leggett—who proposes to her on the spot. Jessie runs off and the battle of wills explodes in Jessie/Timothy John’s mind—and Timothy John wins. When Leggett finds Timothy John and not Jessie, he realizes the truth which sends him into a religious fit forcing Timothy John to run him off. Agonized and feeling the way he did fifteen years ago, Timothy John vows to destroy the painful memories and sets his house on fire. With the house up in flames, Sue Ella rushes over to find Timothy John unharmed, as does Leggett, fearing he’s caused Timothy John’s death. The two realize they are meant to be together, but, as Sue Ella wisely points out, not in Splendora, so she helps the two escape and blames Miss Jessie’s disappearance on the tragic fire.

  • By the Sea, by the Sea, by the Beautiful Sea

    Written by Terrence McNally

    Written by Lanford Wilson

    Directed by Leonard Foglia

    Featured Cast

    Lee Brock, Mary Beth Fisher, Holt McCallany

    A trio of stories told in order

    Dawn: Quentin and his sister Veronica, together with his wife Pat, gather at the beach to scatter their mother’s ashes. The act itself is a closure of sorts, but it stirs up conflicts between the three as marital wounds and sibling rivalries never dealt with are finally confronted.

    Day: A playful look at Ace, a local gardener who goes to the beach on his lunch hour and runs into Macy, a sexpot yuppie (complete with a chic beach umbrella and laptop computer). Macy seduces Ace into applying her tanning lotion, but then the gardener’s nutty girlfriend arrives to give them all a run for their money.

    Dusk: Focused on Willy, a hunk at the beach, and the two women, Dana and Marsha, who would do anything to have him. We discover that all three suffer from their own personal prisons from which they need to escape, and luckily they seem to have found the right place and time to do so.

  • The Ugly Duckling

    Directed by Chris Smith

    Featured Cast

    Evan Pappas, Kate Burton, Debra Monk, Veanne Cox, Ruth Williamson, Michael Mandell, Tim Ewing, Peter Slutsker and David Cantler, Chloe Kroeter, Zena Grey, Jane Pakenham, Kyle Ingram
  • The Dear Harold Trilogy

    Written by William Snowden

    Directed by Emma Walton

    Featured Cast

    Julie Halston, Stephen Hamilton, Steve Hofvendahl, Jan Hooks
  • Oblivion Postponed

    Written by Ron Nyswaner

    Directed by Nicholas Martin

    Featured Cast

    Tony Gillan, John Glover, Charley Lang, Debra Monk, James Rebhorn

    Two seemingly disparate American couples meet by chance while sightseeing in Rome. In the course of an impromptu dinner, they are forced to acknowledge the ugly cracks in their relationships, which are not unalike.

  • Blue Light

    Directed by Sidney Lumet

    Featured Cast

    Bob Dishy, Stephen Pearlman, Mercedes Ruehl, Dina Spybey, D.B. Sweeney, Dianne Wiest

    Rosa is placed in a care home by her niece Stella and left behind on her own. The duo, both Jewish Poles and survivors of Auschwitz, deal with their trauma in very different ways. Rosa, by dwelling on it, on the life and child she loved and lost. Stella, by pretending it didn’t happen, hiding her tattoo.

  • Pippin: A Concert Version

    Directed by Peter Webb

    Featured Cast

    Paul V. Ames, Ryan Blaney, Kate Burton, Murphy Davis, Jeffrery C. Ferguson, Dana Ivey, Donna McKechnie, James Stanek

    An orchestral rendition of the music from the renowned musical by Steven Schwartz.

  • Full Gallop: An Evening With Diana Vreeland

    Written by Mark Hampton

    Featured Cast

    Mary Louise Wilson

    Based on the life of Diana Vreeland, who stood at the center of American style for five decades. As editor of Harper’s Bazaar and Vogue magazines, and as a member of the International Cafe Society, she chronicled the extraordinary people and events of her time. FULL GALLOP is a portrait of this remarkable woman at a turning point in her life. Vreeland has just returned home to New York after four months in Europe—a trip she took after being fired from Vogue magazine. She throws an impromptu dinner party in the hope that a wealthy friend who is invited will bankroll her in starting a magazine of her own. Other friends, however, attempt to persuade her to take a job at the famed Metropolitan Museum of Art. In her distinctive style, once she decides in which direction her life will move, she goes at it “full gallop.”

  • Alone at the Beach

    Written by Richard Dresser

    Directed by Susann Brinkley

    Featured Cast

    Julie Boyd, Mia Dillon, Nick Gregory, Allison Janney, Michael Mantell, Geoff Pierson, Judge Reinhold

    George, a mild mannered man in his mid 30’s, inherits a beach house in the Hamptons and rents out rooms to Manhattanites. George has not actually met any of these yuppies from the urban jungle and they turn out to be a motley crew of neurotics who drive him crazy from the moment they arrive. Everyone hilariously survives the experience and some unlikely romances develop before Labor Day and the final trek back to New York City, until next summer?

  • Desdemona

    Written by Paula Vogel

    Directed by Gloria Muzio

    Featured Cast

    Fran Brill, Cherry Jones, J. Smith-Cameron

    As the wrongly accused and suffering wife of Shakespeare’s Othello, Desdemona has long been viewed as the “victim of circumstance.” But as Pulitzer Prize-winner Paula Vogel demonstrates in her comic deconstruction of Shakespeare’s play – aligning tongue-in-cheek humor while raising serious questions as to the role of women through the ages – Desdemona was far from the quivering naïf we’ve all come to know.

    Having slept with Othello’s entire encampment, Desdemona revels in her bawdy tales of conquest. Her foils and rapt listeners are the other integral and re-imagined women of this Shakespeare tragedy: Emilia, Desdemona’s servant and the wife of Iago, and Bianca, now a majestic whore of Cyprus. The reluctantly loyal Emilia pesters Desdemona about a military promotion for her husband. Her motive, however, is that he leave her a wealthy widow, preferably sooner than later. Bianca, now a street-wise yet painfully naive prostitute, visits Desdemona, thinking she is a very good friend and fellow hooker (at least one night a week). Bianca thinks the worst when she discovers that Desdemona knows intimate details of the life of her lover, Cassio. Though Desdemona has never been intimate with Cassio, her life is soon in danger when her husband, Othello, also suspects her of infidelity.

  • Home Fires: A New Musical

    Written by Linda Thorsen Bond

    Written by Charles Busch

    Directed by Kenneth Elliott

    Featured Cast

    Debra Barsha, Amanda Butterbaugh, Mary Cleere Haran, Marcy McGuigan, Jackie Sanders

    Five female singer-instrumentalists, an “all-girl band” that one member dubs “the brassiere brigade,” somewhere in a nowhere town, is looking for a chance to take their show on tour for the troops overseas, despite not thinking they are good enough.

  • Men’s Lives

    Written by Joe Pintauro

    Featured Cast

    The story of a fictitious fishing family on the East End on the cusp of change. Baymen by history and by livelihood, the family adapts as pollution, overfishing and community changes result in fewer fish to catch. When haul-seining is outlawed by the New York State government, their lives are changed forever.

  • Three Hotels

    Written by Jon Robin Baitz

    Directed by Joe Mantello

    Featured Cast

    Ron Rukin, Maria Tucci

    Monologues set in hotel rooms, two by an American businessman who sells defective baby formula in third world markets and one by his wife, portray a former 1960’s idealist, Hoyle, who has succumbed to the corruption so endemic to modern America. His wife talks about him, their marriage and their son who was murdered for his cheap but expensive looking wristwatch as she prepares to deliver a speech to other corporate wives. In the final hotel room, Hoyle has been fired, his marriage is over and he finally mourns for his son.

Bay Street Theater strives to make our theater performances accessible to EVERYONE. Our primary mission is to Inspire, Entertain and Educate audiences of all backgrounds. Bay Street’s unique PAY WHAT YOU CAN ticket program helps us achieve our goal of making theater available to ALL. Our special PAY WHAT YOU CAN theater nights are a big highlight of our programming each year!

Sponsored By

Cuneo Group, Merrill Lynch
Account Number: 787-04G50
DTC: 8862

Scott R. Blair
Managing Director | CPFA ®, C.R.P.C. ™ 
Senior Financial Advisor | Senior Portfolio Advisor
Retirement Benefits Consultant
NMLS ID: 578993

Merrill Lynch Wealth Managment
300 Broadhollow Road, 2nd Floor 
Melville, NY 11747

T: 631-546-9501
C: 516-254-4648
F: 516-279-3208
S_Blair@ml.com

Please alert tracy@baystreet.org that you have made a stock transfer. For specific questions, please email: kim@baystreet.org

Any student with a valid ID can attend one of Bay Street Theater’s Sunday performances for FREE! Please visit our Box Office for more details.

Sponsored By

You may qualify for a tax deduction while supporting a cause that is near and dear to your heart! Vehicle donation pick-up is always free to you and most vehicles can be picked up within 24-72 hours. You’ll receive an initial car donation receipt upon pick-up and then the CARS team will work to turn your car into cash to support our cause. Once your vehicle is sold, CARS will provide you proper tax forms in time to file. CARS’ friendly Donor Support Representatives are here 7 days a week to assist throughout the process.