Silent Auction 2025 is Now Open! View Items & Bid

35 Years of Award-Winning Performances
View Timeline
GalaCalendarTicketsSubscriptions

Search Bay Street Theater

Tickets Selling Fast

Summer Season ∙ June 30–July 26, 2026
Summer Season
June 30–July 26, 2026

Cagney

Music by Robert Creighton and Christopher McGovern

Hollywood's Tough Guy In Tap Shoes.

TicketsLearn More

    Tickets Selling Fast

Summer Season ∙ August 4–August 29, 2026
Summer Season
August 4–August 29, 2026

Dear Evan Hansen

Bay Street reimagines the Tony Award-winning musical.

TicketsLearn More
    Summer Season ∙ September 2–September 06, 2026
    Summer Season
    September 2–September 06, 2026

    Bonkers in the Boroughs

    The world premiere of Joy Behar's newest show

    TicketsLearn More
      Comedy Series ∙​​ June 27 ∙ 8:00pm

      David Koechner

      The Office, Anchorman, and Saturday Night Live alumnus David Koechner sweeps into Sag Harbor for one night only to make you laugh.

      TicketsLearn More
        Music Mondays ∙​​ July 6 ∙ 8:00pm

        An Evening with Jason Robert Brown

        Four-time Tony Award-winning composer and lyricist Jason Robert Brown comes to Bay Street for a special one-night-only concert event.

        TicketsLearn More
        Music Mondays ∙​​ August 10 ∙ 8:00pm

        Tom Kitt

        An evening of music and storytelling shared from the piano by the award-winning composer.

        TicketsLearn More
          Music Mondays ∙​​ August 17 ∙ 8:00pm

          Melissa Errico: The Streisand Effect

          Tony-nominated Broadway star and longtime Bay Street favorite Melissa Errico returns with her acclaimed new concert event The Streisand Effect: Melissa Sings Barbra

          TicketsLearn More
            Harlem Gospel Choir performing live in a joyful concert celebrating the music of Whitney Houston and Tina Turner.
            Music Mondays ∙​​ August 24 ∙ 8:00pm

            Harlem Gospel Choir: Remembering Whitney & Tina

            The music of Whitney Houston & Tina Turner

            TicketsLearn More

            • Summer Season Subscriptions

              Get 10% off standard ticket prices and priority access to the best seats for the best price before the general public, as well as access to exclusive events.

              Subscribe Now
              • three actors smoking and drinking
              • close up of a woman holding an umbrella
              • three women waving their hands in the air
              • three women looking off in the distant
              • close up of an actress with a hat
              • man and woman performing to each other holding a book
              • three women sitting at desks
              • group of actors sitting at desks
              • actress smoking cigar close up
              • two actors performing to each other
              • man and woman looking at each other
              • two actors performing on stage
              • three actors saying cheers with their glasses
              • man and woman in a romantic scene
              • two actors performing smoking cigars
              • three actors performing holding cigars
              • man and woman performing dressed up on stage
              • woman performing with her arms out toward the roof
              • man and woman in romantic scene dressed up
              • actors sitting at school desks
              • three actors smoking and drinking
              • close up of a woman holding an umbrella
              • three women waving their hands in the air
              • three women looking off in the distant
              • close up of an actress with a hat
              • man and woman performing to each other holding a book
              • three women sitting at desks
              • group of actors sitting at desks
              • actress smoking cigar close up
              • two actors performing to each other
              • man and woman looking at each other
              • two actors performing on stage
              • three actors saying cheers with their glasses
              • man and woman in a romantic scene
              • two actors performing smoking cigars
              • three actors performing holding cigars
              • man and woman performing dressed up on stage
              • woman performing with her arms out toward the roof
              • man and woman in romantic scene dressed up
              • actors sitting at school desks

              What's On

              • Tickets Selling Fast

              Cagney

              June 30—July 26, 2026

              Melissa Manchester Playing Ma Cagney at Bay Street Theater
              Featuring
              Melissa Manchester
              Ma Cagney
              Featuring
              Robert Creighton
              James Cagney
              TicketsMore Info

            • Memberships For All

              Your Membership is an all-access pass to experience live theater like never before.

              Memberships
              • two people talking
              • two men performing on stage

              Where Stars are MADE

              Donate

              We can't do it without you. Donate to Bay Street Theater now and your dollars will go to immediate use. Thank you. Truly.
              Donate Today

              thank you to our Sponsors

              thank you to our funders 

              Pay What You Can

              Bay Street Theater strives to make our theater performances accessible to EVERYONE. Our primary mission is to Inspire, Entertain and Educate audiences of all backgrounds. Bay Street’s unique PAY WHAT YOU CAN ticket program helps us achieve our goal of making theater available to ALL. Our special PAY WHAT YOU CAN theater nights are a big highlight of our programming each year!

              Sponsored By

              Stock Transfer Information

              Cuneo Group, Merrill Lynch
              Account Number: 787-04G50
              DTC: 8862

              Scott R. Blair
              Managing Director | CPFA ®, C.R.P.C. ™ 
              Senior Financial Advisor | Senior Portfolio Advisor
              Retirement Benefits Consultant
              NMLS ID: 578993

              Merrill Lynch Wealth Managment
              300 Broadhollow Road, 2nd Floor 
              Melville, NY 11747

              T: 631-546-9501
              C: 516-254-4648
              F: 516-279-3208
              S_Blair@ml.com

              Please alert tracy@baystreet.org that you have made a stock transfer. For specific questions, please email: kim@baystreet.org

              Free Student Sundays!

              Any student with a valid ID can attend one of Bay Street Theater’s Sunday performances for FREE! Please visit our Box Office for more details.

              Sponsored By

              Qualify for a Tax Deduction

              You may qualify for a tax deduction while supporting a cause that is near and dear to your heart! Vehicle donation pick-up is always free to you and most vehicles can be picked up within 24-72 hours. You’ll receive an initial car donation receipt upon pick-up and then the CARS team will work to turn your car into cash to support our cause. Once your vehicle is sold, CARS will provide you proper tax forms in time to file. CARS’ friendly Donor Support Representatives are here 7 days a week to assist throughout the process.