Buy Tickets Online

Search for the show you want to see on our calendar to purchase your tickets online.

Mainstage Subscriptions

Subscribe NOW for the best seats, advance notice of special events, & many more benefits at one low cost.

Box Office

Call or stop by to purchase tickets to shows. The Box office is open everyday from 11 am-Showtime.

Become a member today
and get special deals on tickets and inside access to events

Box Office Information

Tickets may be purchased via:


Bay Street Theater
P.O. Box 810
Sag Harbor, NY 11963


Box Office: 631-725-9500

At The Theater:

Corner of Bay St. and Main St. Downtown Sag Harbor

The following handling fees apply:

$8 handling charge per ticket (not per order) for all phone, online, and mail orders.

$3 facility fee for all tickets purchased at Box Office and paid for by credit card.

Note: Tickets purchased at the Box Office window by cash/check are not subject to handling or facility charges. Fees for purchasing Mainstage Subscriptions may still apply.



$10 processing fee per subscription when paying by credit card.

$5 processing fee per subscription when paying by check.


Online purchases are subject to additional processing fees.

You must show a photo I.D. or a credit card to pick up your tickets.


Seating Chart

See detailed seating chart

Additional Information

All sales are final. There are no refunds. There is a $20 exchange per performance (based upon availability.) If you are unable to use your tickets, please consider giving your ticket to a friend or family member. You may also donate your ticket back to the theater with the possibility of receiving a tax-deductible receipt if the show sells out.

Special group rates for 20 or more people are available. For more information, please call the Box Office at 631-725-9500.  


The following discounts are only available through the Box Office (not online).

Discounts are available to the following groups upon proof of ID:

  • Students
  • Veterans
  • Seniors
  • $20 UNDER 20
    If you are under the age of 20 you can get your ticket for a Mainstage show for just $20!
  • $30 UNDER 30
    If you are under the age of 30 you can get your ticket for a Mainstage show for just $30!

Other discounts may be available for select performances. For further inquiries please call the box office at 631-725-9500.


Bay Street Theater Gift Cards make a wonderful gift and can be issued in any denomination. For information or to purchase Gift Cards please contact the Box Office.