From New York City and Nassau County
Take the Long Island Expressway to Exit 70 (Manorville). Go south on County Road 111 to 27 East (towards Montauk). Continue for approximately 24 miles to the T-Junction/traffic light in Southampton. Turn left onto Montauk Highway, following signs to East Hampton. Go through Water Mill and enter Bridgehampton. At the end of Bridgehampton's Main Street, turn left at the war memorial/4-way traffic light onto the Sag Harbor Turnpike/CR 79. Continue straight, approximately 4 miles, into the town of Sag Harbor (Turnpike becomes Main Street). Bay Street Theater is at the foot of Main Street (and the corner of Bay Street) on the Long Wharf, opposite the windmill.
From the North Shore
Take the North Ferry from Greenport to Shelter Island. Travel along Route 114 following signs for the South Ferry. Take the South Ferry to North Haven and continue on Ferry Road to the rotary. Turn left around the rotary and continue straight over the bridge to Sag Harbor. Bay Street Theater will be visible on the Long Wharf, opposite the windmill.
Please drive carefully and allow time for parking.
Click Here for Link to the Hampton Jitney
If you’re traveling by the Hampton Jitney, you want to take the Montauk line to Sag Harbor and can then walk a few blocks from the bus stop to the theater. Please check schedules carefully.
If you are taking the train from NYC, you should head to Bridgehampton and then take a taxi. Pre-arranging a taxi or car service is suggested.
Click Here for Link to the Long Island Rail Road
By Ferry from Connecticut and/or Shelter Island
Take the Cross Sound Ferry from New London, CT to Orient, NY. Follow Rte 25 from Orient into Greenport and follow the signs to the North Ferry. Take the North Ferry from Greenport to Shelter Island. Once on Shelter Island follow the signs to the South Ferry. Take the South Ferry over to Sag Harbor, NY. Follow the signs to Sag Harbor. Once over the bridge into Sag Harbor, the Bay Street Theater is the first building on the left on the Long Wharf.
Click Here for Link to the Cross Sound Ferry
Click Here for Link to the North Ferry in Greenport
Click Here for Link to the South Ferry in Shelter Island
Parking At Bay Street Theater
The Wharf is now paid parking. Payment is made through an APP on your phone. The first hour is free. Each subsequent hour is $4.
BEWARE: Curbside parking in front of the theater is 30 minutes only.
Alternative parking can be found at the municipal lot on Water Street next to the Post Office. It's FREE and in walking distance.