2024 Mainstage Subscriptions


2024 Mainstage Subscriptions Are Now Available!

Click Here To Purchase

Save up to 10% on standard ticket prices!

2024 Mainstage Season Subscription:
One seat to each of the three shows on the 2024 Mainstage calendar.

ALL THREE mainstage productions!

Choose the day of the week and performance time, and your seat will be ready and waiting for you.

The fixed seating package will allow you to sit in the same seat for each show, and roll your seat selection over to future seasons. 

Benefits Include:

  • Save more than 10% on standard ticket prices.
  • Best seats for the best price
  • Best seats available in house before the general public.
  • Unlimited free ticket exchanges if plans change (no fee change if purchase is within the same category) 
  • Subscribers are given first access to retain their same seats or upgrade if they wish.
  • Seats are exchangeable for different dates (based on availability) so if you get sick or your plans change, no need to worry! Simply call the box office and let them know.
  • Early access to certain shows
  • Parties
  • Discounts
  • And more!

    Price ranges for the Season Subscription are:
    Premium Seating starting $351.87
    Regular Seating starting at $257.37 
    *Premium seating includes the first five rows in all three Center sections.

Bay Street Box Office: 631-725-9500 | boxoffice@baystreet.org

The Subject Was Roses

May 28 - June 16

(May 28 - June 16, previews May 28 - 31, opening June 1)

Book By Frank D. Gilroy


Talia Balsam

John Slattery

Harry Slattery

Directed by Scott Wittman 

Like roses, family relationships are beautiful but thorny. This Pulitzer Prize and two-time Tony Award-winning play is a poignant drama set in The Bronx in 1946 about the emotional struggles and hidden tensions within a family as their son returns from service in WWII. As they confront their past and present, this timeless play explores enduring themes of reconciliation and the fragility of love. 



Master Class

June 25 - July 20

(previews June 25-28th, opening June 29)

By Terrence McNally

A Comedy with Music

Directed by Lisa Peterson

Master Class is a virtuoso exploration of art, ego, and the pursuit of perfection. In the waning years of her life and with her career far behind her, opera diva Maria Callas retreats into memories of acclaim and adversity while contending with her students during a funny and brutal master class in singing.


Mel Brooks’ Young Frankenstein

The Musical

August 1 – August 25

(August 1st - 25th, previews August 1st & 2nd, opening August 3)

In Association with Berkshire Theatre Group & Geva Theatre

Music & lyrics by Mel Brooks

Book by Mel Brooks & Thomas Meehan

Original direction & choreography by Susan Stroman

Directed by Stuart Ross

Choreography by Gerry Mcintyre


 The comedic genius of Mel Brooks combines with classic B-movie horror in this hilarious musical based on his beloved film. The young American doctor Frederick Frankenstein (“that’s pronounced Fronkensteen!”) is summoned to Transylvania to claim his Grandfather Victor’s estate. Little does he know that this journey will change not only his life, but those of everyone around him, including his sidekick Igor, the beautiful assistant Inga, and a brand-new Monster made for Musical Comedy Heaven. Brace yourself for a wild and inventive production of this side-splitting musical comedy from the director and choreographer of Bay Street’s hit Enter Laughing.


A Fourth Bonus Show
The World Premiere of 


July 15 - July 20

A one-woman play by and starring Julia Motyka

Life isn't lived by the numbers. As she awaits the answer to one of life's big questions, a woman explores the nature of faith and her own complicated family. The hit of the 2023 New Works Festival, this premiere from Bay Street favorite Julia Motyka wrestles with the seen and unseen forces that shape our lives.


The 2024 Mainstage Season at Bay Street Theater is made possible, in part, by the Bay Street Theater Board of Trustees, The Shubert Foundation, New York State Council on the Arts, Suffolk County Department of Economic Development and Planning: Office of Cultural Affairs, AARP Long Island, Aboff's Paints, Adam Miller Group, Advantage Title, Baron's Cove, Bartlett Tree, Ben Krupinski Builders, Channing Daughters, Corcoran, Dayton, Ritz + Osborne Insurance, DiSunno Architecture, Fisher's Home Furnishings, Grenning Gallery, Harbor Pets, Hollander Design Landscape Architects, Jewish Center of the Hamptons, LaGuardia Design Group, Maggio Environmental Services, Mala Sander + Team, Northwell Health, Peconic Landing, PSEG Long Island, The Awning Company, Unlimited Earth Care, Weber & Grahn, Weill Cornell Medicine, and Provisions.