All Star Comedy

This event has past. For upcoming events please click here.

April 6
at 8:00pm

All Star Comedy
Saturday, April 6 at 8pm
Hosted by Jamie Roberts featuring Oscar Aydin and Regina DeCicco 

 Jamie Roberts

Jamie Roberts is a name synonymous with many things including determined, focused, and laugh-out-loud funny. He possesses a persona that warms up the crowd and brings down the house. Jamie’s comedic timing and ability to turn any situation humorous have made him one of the most sought-after hosts in the New York City area. From film to the stage, Jamie is a comic’s comic – you never know what he may say or do next. Jamie has been featured on MTV, Tidal, Sirius XM Radio, The Grio, The Root, 770 WABC Radio (NYC), NBC’s Law & Order, Channel 7 ABC’s (NYC) Eyewitness, Channel 6 ABC News (Philadelphia) commercials. He was also a cast member on FYI’s A Question of Love, with his then-girlfriend Nicky Sunshine starring on the show for 10 episodes. Who would have thought this Long Island native would have what it takes to make it in the big city? Jamie is currently married to his comedy sweetheart Nicky Sunshine, and they are now touring with their brand “Married and Funny.” He is also the founder and executive director of Comedy with A Purpose. A business in which he uses comedy to address some serious social matters. Jamie is also the owner of Comedy In Harlem which is New York’s new comedy club located uptown in Harlem USA. With his clean-cut good looks, insatiable charm, and cutting-edge comedy, Jamie Roberts is the one to watch in the upcoming year.

Oscar Aydin

Oscar Aydin is a New York City based comedian and host known for his unfiltered "rainbow pushing" style. He’s been featured on BBC, Daily Mail, Queerty LOL and as guest commentator on Amazon. He is a regular across NYC clubs including The Stand, New York Comedy Club and Greenwich Village Comedy, and has performed on stages alongside Nikki Glaser, Anthony Jeselnik and Andrew Shulz. He’s also featured across the US for comedians such as Ashley Hesseltine, Hannah Berner and Jessica Kirson. Oscar hosts the hilarious bi-weekly podcast, "Oh Oscar!” where guests share their wild, crazy, and sometimes awkward date and hook-up stories on the popular and hysterical segment, "Dickssappointed.” His audacious personality has won over both live and digital crowds, leaving them saying "Oh Oscar!!" and steadily coming back for more.

Regina DeCicco 

 Regina DeCicco is the warm-up comedian for ABC's "The View," and she recently appeared on Sherri Shepherd's show as part of her "Laugh Lounge" segment. ABC News sent Regina to Philadelphia to warm up both President Joe Biden's and President Trump's Town Halls, and she has warmed up the audience for NBC's Rockefeller Center Christmas Tree Lighting for the last three years. Regina has also been a guest contributor to The Howard Stern Show on SiriusXM and performs regularly at The Comedy Cellar in NYC.

Other Shows

Live Taping - Half Hard Half Soft
Category: Events April 27 at 8:00pm

Live Taping of a one-hour comedy special with Joe Vecsey.

Waiting in the Wings book discussion with Julie Andrews and Emma Walton Hamilton
Category: Events April 28 at 3:00pm

Beloved icon Julie Andrews and her daughter, bestselling author Emma Walton Hamilton, have written a charming celebration of the arts born from a true story in WAITING IN THE WINGS. One spring, outside of the Bay Street Theater on Long Island, NY, a family of ducks nested and hatched in a nearby planter and paraded down to the water while theater staff looked on. As co-founder of the theater, Emma was front and center that day, and WAITING IN THE WINGS takes that inspiration to depict a fun, kid-friendly story that highlights the wonders of theater – co-written by one of the greatest icons of stage and screen.

Met Opera Live in HD 2024 Season
Category: Events October 21 through May 11

Bay Street Theater will be screening the Metropolitan Opera’s 2023–2024 season through the Met Opera: Live in HD Audiences will be able to experience spectacular productions, transmitted directly from the Met’s stage in New York City. With a mix of company premieres, new productions, and classic repertory favorites the season is set to deliver incredible performances at Bay Street.

10th Annual New Works Festival
Category: Events May 17 through May 19

The 10th annual Title Wave: 2024 New Works Festival returns to the stage at Bay Street Theater bringing with it four bold and exciting new plays currently in development. Dutch Masters - A Musical Music and Lyrics by Jeffrey Stock Book by Marc Acito; House of India by Deepak Kumar; The Ordeal of Water by Stephanie Alison Walker; and Polar Bears, Black Boys, & Prairie Fringed Orchids by Vincent Terrell Durham.

The Subject Was Roses
Category: Events May 28 through June 16

Like roses, family relationships are beautiful but thorny. This Pulitzer Prize and two-time Tony Award-winning play is a poignant drama set in The Bronx in 1946 about the emotional struggles and hidden tensions within a family as their son returns from service in WWII. As they confront their past and present, this timeless play explores enduring themes of reconciliation and the fragility of love.

Summer Sunday Tea Dances
Category: Events June 9 through August 25

The mixers will be the perfect casual antidote for wrapping up a weekend on the East End! Plus, attendees are invited to come early or stay after to catch a show on Bay Street's Mainstage, with Sunday matinee performances at 2 p.m. and evening performances at 7 pm. The series of events will offer creative cocktail specials, light bites, theme days, fabulous music, and LOTS OF DANCING.

Music Mondays Patti LuPone: A Life in Notes
Category: Events July 8 at 8:00pm

Music Mondays Return! The hit summer concert series that invites artists to perform for audiences and share stories of their time on and off the stage is held Mondays through July and August starting with Patti LuPone on July 8; The Harlem Gospel Choir on August 5; Erich Bergen on August 12; and finishing with a performance of Ari Axelrod on August 19.

Mike Birbiglia: Please Stop the Ride
Category: Events July 25 through July 28

Mike Birbiglia for four nights this Summer: Thursday, July 25th @ 6 pm, Friday, July 26th @ 7 pm, Saturday, July 27th @ 6 pm, Saturday, July 27th @ 8:30 pm and Sunday, July 28th @ 2PM, to perform his newest show "Mike Birbiglia: Please Stop the Ride". Birbiglia returns to Bay Street Theater, by popular demand, on the heels of his DOUBLE SOLD-OUT performances last summer of "The Old Man and the Pool" which debuted at Bay Street Theater and went on to be a hit Broadway show and Netflix comedy special.

Music Mondays with The Harlem Gospel Choir, Erich Bergen, and Ari Axelrod
Category: Events August 5 through August 19

Music Mondays Return! The hit summer concert series that invites artists to perform for audiences and share stories of their time on and off the stage is held Mondays through July and August starting with Patti LuPone on July 8; The Harlem Gospel Choir on August 5; Erich Bergen on August 12; and finishing with a performance of Ari Axelrod on August 19.