All Star Comedy

March 16
at 8:00pm

$37 -$47 + processing fees

Purchase Tickets

or call our Box office (631) 725-9500

All Star Comedy
Saturday, March 16 at 8pm
Featuring Pete Cestaro, Marc Gerber, and Harris Stanton

Pete Cestaro 

Pete Cestaro is a bicoastal comedian spending his time between New York and California, mostly because he hates the winter and loves the ocean but also for the proximity to the country’s best comedy clubs. He’s hosted College Sports Television, AMC’s Date Night, and is a member of the Bridgehampton Softball Hall of Fame

Marc Gerber


Marc Gerber is a born and bred New Yorker who has been performing stand-up for over 10 years in New York City and beyond. Marc's first album, Avid Indoorsman, debuted as number one on the iTunes comedy charts, and is still in rotation on multiple SiriusXM comedy stations three years after its initial release. Amazon Music recently featured a track from Marc's album on its Very Funny playlist, along with giants like Dave Chapelle and Bo Burnham. Marc was recently featured as a comic to watch on Access Hollywood, promoting his second album which was recorded as part of the New York Comedy Festival. Equally adept at satirizing the State of the Union and the state of his own affairs, Marc has been featured on CNN’s RunningMate podcast, The Steve Harvey Show and MTV, just to name a few.

  Harris Stanton

 Harris Stanton is a American comedian based in Brooklyn. Harris attened spartnburg methodist college in spartanburg south Carolina.  In 1996, he was drafted by the Chicago cubs in the 52 round of the major league amateur draft. He decided  to pursue comedy leading to a almost two decade-long career. Harris tours nationally and internationally including appearances on European television. He has been featured on BET's comic view, premium Blend and comics unleashed . He recorded a comedy dvd with patrice oneal , "elephant in the room". And his own comedy album naive innocence was in the top 10 for 2 weeks on the itunes stand up comedy album charts!

Other Shows

A Theatrical Excursion to Naples, Florida
Category: Events March 1 through March 4

Join Executive Director Tracy Mitchell for a four day adventure in the sun!

REEB And Souled Out
Category: Events March 9 at 8:00pm

Turn Up The Brass with REEB, Real East End Brass, and Long Island’s Exclusive Dance Band Souled Out!

Kissed by a Prince—A Tribute
Category: Events March 23 at 8:00pm

On April 21, 2016, the world lost one of the most profound musical artists of our time: Prince Rogers Nelson. Since his 1978 debut album, For You, his music has filled the airwaves with raw musical emotion. All of the performers have been inspired by the music of Prince, and now they have joined forces for the first time to bring his music to a live audience.

The HooDoo Loungers & Friends with Special Guests The Belle Curves
Category: Events March 30 at 8:00pm

The HooDoo Loungers take their inspiration from the Gri Gri of Dr. John to the Swingin' Rock N' Roll of Fats Domino. They Blend it all together with a bit of classic soul and New Orleans Swing for an inspired and original musical gumbo.

All Star Comedy
Category: Events April 6 at 8:00pm

All Star Comedy Saturday, April 6 at 8pm Hosted by Jamie Roberts featuring Oscar Aydin and Regina DeCicco

Ha Ha Hamptons Comedy Tour
Category: Events April 13 at 8:00pm

One would rarely if ever see this much comic talent on one stage at any comedy club venue in the US! HA HA Hamptons Comedy Tour presents 4 performers and a surprise guest appearing Saturday, April 13th, 8 pm show time.

The Absolute Adele Tribute
Category: Events April 20 at 8:00pm

The Absolute Adele Tribute, delivers a stunningly accurate portrayal of the British songstress and pop icon, an artist.

Live Taping - Half Hard Half Soft
Category: Events April 27 at 8:00pm

Live Taping of a one-hour comedy special with Joe Vecsey.

Waiting in the Wings book discussion with Julie Andrews and Emma Walton Hamilton
Category: Events April 28 at 3:00pm

Beloved icon Julie Andrews and her daughter, bestselling author Emma Walton Hamilton, have written a charming celebration of the arts born from a true story in WAITING IN THE WINGS. One spring, outside of the Bay Street Theater on Long Island, NY, a family of ducks nested and hatched in a nearby planter and paraded down to the water while theater staff looked on. As co-founder of the theater, Emma was front and center that day, and WAITING IN THE WINGS takes that inspiration to depict a fun, kid-friendly story that highlights the wonders of theater – co-written by one of the greatest icons of stage and screen.

Met Opera Live in HD 2024 Season
Category: Events October 21 through May 11

Bay Street Theater will be screening the Metropolitan Opera’s 2023–2024 season through the Met Opera: Live in HD Audiences will be able to experience spectacular productions, transmitted directly from the Met’s stage in New York City. With a mix of company premieres, new productions, and classic repertory favorites the season is set to deliver incredible performances at Bay Street.