2024 Gala

This event has past. For upcoming events please click here.

July 6
at 7:00pm


Center Seating $2,500. 

Side Seating $1,750.

Questions? Contact Kim or Mick at 631.725.0818

Considering becoming a patron? Click Here.


Food! Cocktails! Auction!
And a show that will knock your socks off!

Oh yes, and did we mention... Stars!?!

Join Bay Street Theater for its 32nd Annual Gala

July 6, 2024 at 7pm

Join us along with this year’s honorees: Broadway show-stopper Neil Patrick Harris, David Burtka, and outstanding community leader Dr. Georgette Grier-Key.

Bay Street's Gala is THE biggest and most important fundraising event of the year as it helps support all of the artists who work here and the educational programming that lies at the center of our mission.

Who: You! 

What: An amazing night of fun!

Where: Bay Street Theater, Sag Harbor 

When: Saturday, July 6th, 2024

Why: Because the arts are important for everyone. Art should not be a privilege. 

    Tiffany Boxes are back again this year! You may purchase them for $150/ea with a chance to win a $2,000 Tiffany Gift Certificate.

(Boxes only available to Gala ticket purchasers)


Auction Items

Walk on Role with tickets and dinner for 8 at American Hotel

Dinner with Chef Matteo for 8

Thanksgiving Day Parade in NYC with brunch for 10-20

A week in St. Barts for 4 with Tradewind Aviation roundtrip San Juan to St. Barts

Balmain VIP Fashion Show: 5 day trip to Paris plus $10,000 gift certificate 

More to Be Announced!

Bay Street Theater works hard in creating inclusivity for everyone! The programs are many and include ‘Pay What You Can Nights’, ‘Free Student Sundays’, Free theater for schools every fall, and so much more. Bolstered by a policy that “Anyone who wishes to have access to the arts will have it at Bay Street Theater”, we promise you that your investment will go far at Bay Street Theater. 

We thank you. And our community thanks you. 


Neil Patrick Harris 

David Burtka

Also Honoring Community Leader

Dr. Georgette Grier-Key

Celebrity Auctioneer

Richard Kind


David Fink and Flora Schnall

Gala Committee 

Jennifer Bartley
Kim Fink
Myra Hackel
Wendy Harrison Hashmall
Ashley Howe
Mick Johnson
Riki Kane Larimer
Nina Lesavoy
Elise Leve
Leslie Mayer
Tracy Mitchell, Executive Director

Board Members

Steven Todrys, Chair
Patty Baker
Jennifer Bartley
Joy Behar
David Fink
John Frawley
Dan Gasby
Loretta Kaufman
Myra Hackel
Wendy Harrison Hashmall
Richard Kind
Carol Konner
Stewart F. Lane
Riki Kane Larimer
Nina Lesavoy
Elise Leve
Tracy A. Mitchell, Executive Director
Mala Sander
Flora Schnall
Scott Schwartz, Artistic Director
Eric Segal
Christine Wächter-Campbell

Honorary Gala Host Committee

Hilary Ackermann
Frederico Azevedo
Patty and Jay Baker
Jennifer Bartley
Joy Behar
Ann Ciardullo & Keith Green
Bonnie Comley & Stewart Lane
Valerie & Rich Davis
Marcy Epstein
Katarina & Leslie Feldman
David Fink & Simon Kinsella
Candace & John Frawley
Dan Gasby
Myra Hackel
Wendy Harrison Hashmall & David Hashmall
Cornelia & Ralph Heins
Ashley Howe & Michael Scissons
Alba Jancou & Peter Cook
Loretta & Victor Kaufman
Richard Kind
Carol Konner
Riki Kane Larimer
Nina Lesavoy
Elise Leve & Robert Cyruli
Brian K. Lewis & Matthew Hemberger
Ed Littlefield
Leslie & Jordan Mayer
Tracy Mitchell
Sarah Jessica Parker & Matthew Broderick
David Reale
Mala & Jeff Sander
Flora Schnall
Scott Schwartz
Joyce & Eric Segal
Bruce Sloane & Doug Petri
Robin & Joe Sparacio
Karol & Steve Todrys
Tyler Whitman
Christine Wächter-Campbell & Bill Campbell

In Memory Of

 Luigi Caiola

This Year’s Gala is being held in memory of Luigi Caiola, dear friend, colleague, and Trustee, who devoted his life to his two greatest passions, family and theater. He will be forever missed.

Click Here To Make A Donation

For more info call 631-725-0818 or contact kim@baystreet.org





Bay Street Theater is a year-round, not-for-profit professional theater and community cultural center, which endeavors to innovate, educate, and entertain a diverse community through the practice of the performing arts. It serves as a social and cultural gathering place, an educational resource, and a home for a community of artists.
Become a Patron Member today and get first access to all of Bay Street's special events throughout the year!
For more information on Membership, click HERE.

 For more info call 631-725-0818 or contact kim@baystreet.org