Silent Auction 2025 is Now Open! View Items & Bid

35 Years of Award-Winning Performances
View Timeline

About

Interactive Timeline

Explore 35 years of award-winning performances at Bay Street Theater

Since 1991, Bay Street Theater has been a beacon and a home for live theater. Many of the productions that have premiered or were developed at Bay Street Theater have moved to Broadway, Off-Broadway, regionally and abroad.

Who We Are

Bay Street Theater is a provider of live, intimate, high-quality theater experiences featuring top-tier artists in a unique setting. Many of the productions that have premiered or were developed at Bay Street Theater have moved to Broadway, Off-Broadway, regionally and abroad.

Board of trusteesJunior BoardBay Street Staff
  • On Camera Camp
  • full audience surrounding man on stage
  • Audience applauding during a 2026 Summer Mainstage performance at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor
  • four actors in a play
  • full live audience in theater
  • live band performing
    The "Beatles vs. the Rolling Stones Battle of the Bands" at the Bay Street Theater on Saturday, February 7th, 2015

“Bay Street Theater is about the top artists in the world coming together and creating visionary new takes on well known titles and new works on our stage. It’s about the words ‘intimacy’ and ‘closeness’ and ‘heat.’"

– Scott Schwartz, Artistic Director

Our Mission

Bay Street Theater is a year-round, not-for-profit professional theater and community cultural center, which endeavors to innovate, educate, motivate, and entertain a diverse community through the performing arts. We serve as a beacon, a social and cultural gathering place, an educational resource, a center for innovation and new work development, and an ever-expanding home for a community of artists.  

Great Gatsby company on stage

2020

Bay Street Moves In

Aliqua id fugiat nostrud irure ex duis ea quis id quis ad et. Sunt qui esse pariatur duis deserunt mollit dolore cillum minim tempor enim elit aute irure tempor cupidatat incididunt.

man and woman in a romantic scene

2021

Mainstage Season Begins

Aliqua id fugiat nostrud irure ex duis ea quis id quis ad et. Sunt qui esse pariatur duis deserunt mollit dolore cillum minim tempor enim elit aute irure tempor cupidatat incididunt.

black color

2022

Lorem ipsum

Aliqua id fugiat nostrud irure ex duis ea quis id quis ad et. Sunt qui esse pariatur duis deserunt mollit dolore cillum minim tempor enim elit aute irure tempor cupidatat incididunt.

black color

2023

Lorem ipsum

Aliqua id fugiat nostrud irure ex duis ea quis id quis ad et. Sunt qui esse pariatur duis deserunt mollit dolore cillum minim tempor enim elit aute irure tempor cupidatat incididunt.

black color background

2024

Lorem ipsum

Aliqua id fugiat nostrud irure ex duis ea quis id quis ad et. Sunt qui esse pariatur duis deserunt mollit dolore cillum minim tempor enim elit aute irure tempor cupidatat incididunt.

black color

Past Performances

(As of March 15, 2026)

Meredith Burns
Kristin Greenblatt
Sam Sklover

Corey Werbelow

Tracy Mitchell, Executive Director
Scott Schwartz, Artistic Director

Mike Billings, Director of Production
Ed Breese, Director of Marketing
Anne Chaisson, Senior Director of Advancement & Major Gifts
Hannah Corbett, Tech Supervisor
Bethany Dellapolla, Director of Education & Community Outreach
Eric Jacobson, Executive Associate/ Special Events Producer
Mick Johnson, Associate Director of Philanthropy
Sherry Lyles, Bookkeeper
Moriah Moore, Marketing Coordinator
Paul Anthony Mongelluzzo, Director of Sponsorships
Will Pomerantz, Associate Artistic Director
Chris Siefert, Deputy Director
John Sullivan, Associate Producer & Company Manager
Nancy Thompson, Front of House Operations Manager
Michael Williams, Senior Box Office Associate

(As of January 01, 2026)

Lynn Mestel, Chair
Keith Green, Co-Vice Chair
Loretta Kaufman, Co-Vice Chair

Nina Lesavoy, Co-Vice Chair

Christine Wächter-Campbell
, Co-Vice Chair
John Frawley, Treasurer
Wendy Harrison Hashmall,
Secretary

Tracy Mitchell, Executive Director
Scott Schwartz, Artistic Director

Jennifer Bartley
Joy Behar
David Fink
Dan Gasby
Myra Hackel
Richard Kind
Carol Konner
Stewart F. Lane
Riki Kane Larimer
Elise Leve
Leslie Mayer
Laura McPhail
Alison Newman
Flora Schnall
Eric Segal
Steve Todrys

TRUSTEES EMERITI
Ana R. Daniel, Chair Emeritus
Julie Andrews
Stanley Arkin
Kay Delaney Bring
Adrianne Cohen
Ted Conklin*
John Downing
Frank Filipo
Patrick E. Malloy III
Luigi Caiola*

*deceased

Bay Street Players Inc.

Donations to this organization are tax deductible.
EIN: 59-1789108

Bay Street Theater strives to make our theater performances accessible to EVERYONE. Our primary mission is to Inspire, Entertain and Educate audiences of all backgrounds. Bay Street’s unique PAY WHAT YOU CAN ticket program helps us achieve our goal of making theater available to ALL. Our special PAY WHAT YOU CAN theater nights are a big highlight of our programming each year!

Sponsored By

Cuneo Group, Merrill Lynch
Account Number: 787-04G50
DTC: 8862

Scott R. Blair
Managing Director | CPFA ®, C.R.P.C. ™ 
Senior Financial Advisor | Senior Portfolio Advisor
Retirement Benefits Consultant
NMLS ID: 578993

Merrill Lynch Wealth Managment
300 Broadhollow Road, 2nd Floor 
Melville, NY 11747

T: 631-546-9501
C: 516-254-4648
F: 516-279-3208
S_Blair@ml.com

Please alert tracy@baystreet.org that you have made a stock transfer. For specific questions, please email: kim@baystreet.org

Any student with a valid ID can attend one of Bay Street Theater’s Sunday performances for FREE! Please visit our Box Office for more details.

Sponsored By

You may qualify for a tax deduction while supporting a cause that is near and dear to your heart! Vehicle donation pick-up is always free to you and most vehicles can be picked up within 24-72 hours. You’ll receive an initial car donation receipt upon pick-up and then the CARS team will work to turn your car into cash to support our cause. Once your vehicle is sold, CARS will provide you proper tax forms in time to file. CARS’ friendly Donor Support Representatives are here 7 days a week to assist throughout the process.