ALL Star Comedy

This event has past. For upcoming events please click here.

October 27
at 8:00pm

All Star Comedy

Advised For Audiences 18+

Friday, October 27 at 8pm
Hosted by JP Justice featuring Tracey Carnazzo and Kevin Israel

JP Justice

This 20-year veteran has established himself as a versatile comedian. His keen sense of audience observation is Seinfeldesque, enhancing his ability to make jokes about anything, under any circumstances. JP JUSTICE was familiar with hard times, and the only thing helping him cope was his ability to make folks laugh. Born into a large family, there was always an audience, and he practiced often. Not surprising, JP JUSTICE’s switch to the big stage was only a matter of time once he overcame many of life’s small tangents. It was an insightful trip JP JUSTICE took to Africa, at the age of 18, that caused him to take a new look at his life and decide to complete high school. While attending a New York City college, he finally realized comedy was his calling, and that is when his career began. JP JUSTICE is swift with snaps and handles hecklers with ease. These capabilities landed him his first big break in 1996, when the world famous Apollo Theater asked him to host their Amateur Night. During this rotation, he sharpened his skills and gained recognition as one of New York’s greatest hosts. He then went on to lead a variety of shows to success; including writing comedy for then popular 98.7 Kiss FM’s (New York) radio morning show with Isaac Hayes and Friends. Shortly after, JP JUSTICE created and co-produced a racy weekly stage variety show called “Wha Da Family”. He was head writer, producer and cast member; proving that live variety shows were still a viable format. JP JUSTICE was also the host of the nucleus of black comedy clubs in NYC, The Uptown Comedy Club. Since then, JP JUSTICE’s stand-up routine has garnered television appearances on The Original Russell Simmons’ Def Comedy Jam, Comic View, Showtime at the Apollo, and Uptown Comedy Club. He has played the “chitlin circuit” and numerous clubs around the world, including headlining at the famous Caroline’s on Broadway, The Improv and Laugh Factory. He has opened for artists such as Chris Rock, Paul Mooney, Bernie Mac, LL Cool J and Tommy Davidson. His unique talent landed him hosting gigs for HBO Comedy Special, Black Expo (various cities), and the Miss Black Teen Pageant. JP JUSTICE also received an award from HBO’s Comic Relief benefit for Dedication to the Homeless. This articulate narrator of the world looks at life and answers through humor. Ready to take the world by storm, and having already left his mark, JP JUSTICE is destined for comedic stardom. Audiences are ready for his straightforward style. Are you?

Tracey Carnazzo

Tracey Carnazzo is a comedian and podcast host from New York City. Her OCD and love for reality TV has shaped who she is today. Tracey hosts the podcasts Teen Mom Trash Talk, 90 Day Fiancé Trash Talk and Catfish Trash Talk, which sit on podcast top charts.

Tracey has performed at New York Comedy Festival, New South Comedy Festival, Free Standup Festival, Skankfest, Asheville Comedy Festival, Cola Comedy Con and Oak City Comedy Festival. She has been featured on SiriusXM’s The Bonfire, Jim & Sam and Tell Me Everything. Tracey can be seen on Elite Daily, Refinery 29, Bravo, MTV, FX, Hulu and VICE. You can hear her as a guest on various comedy podcasts. Tracey is a regular at NYC venues and performs all over the country.

Kevin Israel

Kevin broke his poor Jewish mother’s heart when he left the practice of law to pursue his true passion - stand-up comedy. And while she’s still coming to terms with the reality of his chosen profession, Kevin has honed a one-of-a-kind act that takes you through his life and finds humor in all of it.

Kevin has toured the country regaling audiences with his decades of life experience. From stories about his parents, to relationships, to the reality of growing up the only Jewish kid in his school, when Kevin leaves the stage you won’t just feel that you’ve seen a great show, you’ll know you made a friend.

Kevin has worked with some of the top acts in the nation. He was recently featured on kevin Hart’s LOL Network and he is a USA Today Storyteller. Kevin has guest hosted the Sirius Satellite Radio RawDog comedy morning show and he won the prestigious Gilda Radner’s Laugh-off in 2013. Kevin was a star of the viral hit, “Gym Clowns” which has been viewed 3.3 million times and has contributed to Perez Hilton and TMZ. His comedy album, #TheStruggleIsrael is currently being played on Sirius/XM’s comedy channels.



Other Shows

Met Opera Live in HD 2023-2024 Season
Category: Events October 21 through May 11

Bay Street Theater will be screening the Metropolitan Opera’s 2023–2024 season through the Met Opera: Live in HD Audiences will be able to experience spectacular productions, transmitted directly from the Met’s stage in New York City. With a mix of company premieres, new productions, and classic repertory favorites the season is set to deliver incredible performances at Bay Street.

Judy Carmichael
Category: Events December 9 at 8:00pm

Grammy Award nominated pianist/vocalist/humorist, Judy Carmichael in an evening of swing music from the 1930s and ‘40s.

Holiday Concert Featuring Joe Lauro & members of Hoodoo Loungers + Sarah Conway & the Playful Souls with special tribute to Jimmy Buffett
Category: Events December 18 at 7:30pm

The night will feature performances by Sarah Conway "The Queen of Christmas" and her band The Playful Souls as well as Joe Lauro and Friends from the Hoodoo Loungers performing holiday and Jimmy Buffett favorites. Guests are encouraged to don "Parrot Head" attire such as Hawaiian shirts, flip-flops, and festive Buffettesque headgear to celebrate the epic and wonderful life of local and international treasure (and dear friend of Bay Street Theater) Jimmy Buffett!

Nancy Atlas Fireside Sessions
Category: Events January 6 through January 27

She returns to Bay Street Theater with a brand-new series of Fireside Session concerts, accompanied by special guest musicians.

A Night of Motown with That Motown Band
Category: Events February 24 at 7:00pm

Do you love songs like Heat Wave, Ain’t to proud to beg, Baby Love, Ain’t No Mountain High Enough, My Girl, and Ain’t no Mountain High Enough? Do you love artists like Smokey Robinson, The Temptations, The Supremes and The Four Tops? Then, you are going to love this group of talented vocalists and musicians. That Motown Band has been entertaining Motown fans for years