Buy a Subscription Now
to Attend the 2018 Mainstage Season

What is a subscription?

A subscription is a three ticket package to our 2018 Mainstage season.

What is the difference between a set series subscription and a flex pass subscription?

Set Series: One Subscription equals 3 Tickets, one for each of the main stage Plays. 1 for Play 1, 1 for Play 2, and 1 for Play 3. You will be assigned a particular series for a certain night of the week. For example, if you wanted Tuesday nights you’d be assigned to the first week of every performance or every second week, etc. You will also have the same seats for all three performances.

Flex: One Flex Pass equals 3 tickets to be used however you would like toward the Mainstage Season. You can use 1 ticket for each show, all 3 tickets to Play 1, or 2 tickets to Play 2 and 1 ticket to Play 3. Unlike a set series you are not assigned seats and dates ahead of time.

Can I exchange my dates?

Yes! As a subscriber, you have the option of exchanging your seats at no additional cost, up to 24 hours prior to the show.

Where can I purchase a subscription?

Subscriptions can be purchase online, over the phone, or in person at the box office.

What are the benefits of subscribing?

·  Priority seating for 2018 Mainstage Production

·  Free ticket exchange privileges  (within price level)

·  Early access to single ticket sales

·  Special discounts on other shows

·  Waived phone fees



2018 Mainstage Summer Season!
Get best seats now while they last!

Sunday/Wednesday Matinee - $159

Matinee Flex Pass - $159

Tues/Wed/Sun Evening - $219

Thurs/Fri/Sat Evening - $237

Evening Flex Pass - $237

Saturday Opening Nights (Renewal & Side Seats Only) - $279



World Premiere of FELLOW TRAVELERS
May 29 – June 17
A new play by Jack Canfora

Directed by Michael Wilson

June 26 – July 22
By Peter Morgan

Directed by Sarna Lapine

The musical EVITA
July 31 – August 26
By Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice

Directed by Will Pomerantz

The cast and creative teams will be announced soon. Subscriptions are available by calling the Box Office at 631-725-9500 or online at


Set during Hollywood’s notorious Blacklist, FELLOW TRAVELERS examines the relationship between legendary theater artists Arthur Miller and Elia Kazan and their close connection to Marilyn Monroe. Kazan directed several Miller plays, including DEATH OF A SALESMAN, and Tennessee Williams dramas, including A STREETCAR  NAMED DESIRE. Miller also wrote the modern classics THE CRUCIBLE and A VIEW FROM THE BRIDGE. FELLOW TRAVELERS explores how the politics of the McCarthy era affected their friendship and how their friendship affected their work.

From Peter Morgan, the creator of Netflix’s THE CROWN and the writer of the THE QUEEN, FROST/NIXON revolves around the landmark series of interviews between British journalist David Frost and former President Nixon three years after he resigned. It’s a battle of wits that pits a broadcaster against one of America’s most complex and wily presidents; a riveting story of the collision of politics and the media.

The revival of the beloved musical EVITA, will take a new look at the iconic Eva Perón and her ascent to the top as the First Lady of Argentina. Bay Street Theater will offer its signature treatment of a large scale musical - an intimate experience in a thrust theater that allows the audience to get close to the iconic characters and dig deep into the world of and story of Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s masterpiece. The classic score features some of Webber and Rice’s biggest hits, including "Don’t Cry for Me Argentina," "High Flying, Adored" and "Another Suitcase in Another Hall."


The 2018 Mainstage Season is sponsored in part by New York State through the generosity of Assemblyman Fred Thiele and State Senator Kenneth P. LaValle; the New York State Council on The Arts, a State Agency; Town of Southampton; The Harold and Mimi Steinberg Charitable Trust; The Shubert Foundation; and fully or partially funded by the Suffolk County Department of Economic Development & Planning. Support for new work comes from The New Directions Fund and the Joseph Stein New Musical Fund. Previews are sponsored by Peconic Landing. EVITA sponsored in part by Baron’s Cove. "Pay What You Can" nights are the first preview for each production sponsored by Sotheby's International Realty.


Tuesdays at 7 pm
Wednesdays at 2 and 7 pm
Thursdays at 8 pm
Fridays at 8 pm
Saturdays at 8 pm
Sundays at 2 and 7 pm 

Other Ticket Deals:


$20 Under 20
All guests under the age of 20 may purchase tickets for $20
Subject to availability
Valid ID required

$30 Under 30
All guests under the age of 30 may purchase tickets for $30
Subject to availability
Valid ID required

FREE Student Sunday Matinees
All students with a valid ID may purchase tickets to a Sunday matinee for FREE

Subject to availability
Valid ID required


Call the Box Office for more information