Holiday Sing-a-long

December 18
at 7:00pm

HOLIDAY CONCERT AND SING-A-LONG on Tuesday, December 18 at 7 pm features the Broadway Irish tenor CIARAN SHEEHAN accompanied by pianist BRENDA LANDRUM, and is made possible by the generous gifts of some Bay Street patrons. Suggested donation is $10 and a canned good for our local food pantry.

CIARAN SHEEHAN’S Broadway credits include the role of Raoul in THE PHANTOM OF THE OPERA and Babet in LES MISERABLES. Off Broadway he has played in the Irish Repertory Theatre production of THE IRISH AND HOW THEY GOT THAT WAY, the New York Concert of FINIAN’S RAINBOW, the workshop for THE MOLLY MAGUIRES, and more. Pianist BRENDA LANDRUM is a local favorite and has been an active member of the Sag Harbor community for many years.

The evening begins with a concert followed by a lively holiday sing-a-long.

Other Shows

5th Annual Honors Benefit: Curtain Up!
Category: Events May 9 at 6:00pm

Save the Date! A sneak peek preview of the Summer Mainstage Season.

Goat on a Boat @ Bay Street Presents the Annual Bambini Ball
Category: Events May 20 at 5:30pm

Goat on a Boat will be celebrating its 15th birthday with our annual Bambini Ball at our new home at Bay Street Theater!

Jazz Inspired with Judy Carmichael & Billy Stritch
Category: Events May 21 at 8:00pm

    Grammy-nominated pianist/vocalist Judy Carmichael and Grammy-winning pianist/vocalist Billy Stritch will play, sing and talk about their lives in music. Join us for back-to-back grand pianos! This is...

World Premiere of THE FORGOTTEN WOMAN
Category: Events May 31 through June 19

Single tickets go on sale May 1! World Premiere!
THE FORGOTTEN WOMAN
A New Play by Jonathan Tolins (Writer of Buyer & Cellar)
Directed by Noah Himmelstein
  Margaret Meier is a gifted...

Lisa Lampanelli in STUFFED. A Play about Food, Fat and Fearlessness. Written by Lisa Lampanelli and featuring Broadway's Lisa Howard
Category: Events June 25 at 8:00pm

Comedian/writer/actor Lisa Lampanelli is best-known as “Comedy’s Lovable Queen of Mean.” "Stuffed" is the first in a series of four plays she is penning about important issues to women. A regular on Sirius satellite radio’s “The Howard Stern Show,” Lampanelli has appeared on “The Tonight Show with Jay Leno," “Late Show with David Letterman,” “Chelsea Lately,” “Jimmy Kimmel
Live,” “The Dr. Oz Show,” and “Good Morning America.” She was also a member of the cast of NBC’s “Celebrity Apprentice,” Season 5, raising $130,000 for her charity, the Gay Men's Health Crisis. Ms. Lampanelli has also been nominated twice for Grammy Awards for "Best Comedy Album," and has six, one-hour televised specials, including her HBO special, "Long Live The Queen."

Goat on a Boat @ Bay Street presents Squirrel Stole my Underpants
Category: Events July 7 at 11:00am

Tickets Coming Soon!   The Gottabees A poignantly silly adventure tale for families. 

Sylvie is sent to the backyard to hang up the laundry. The moment her back is turned, a mischievous...

The 25th Annual Summer Gala
Category: Events July 9 at 6:00pm

With Honorary Chairs
Arlene & Alan Alda
Celebrate! Party! Dance! Featuring scenes from selected past Bay Street Productions,
25th Anniversary Film Tribute and More!
Surprise Guests to be...

Goat on a Boat @ Bay Street presents Caps for Sale
Category: Events July 16 at 11:00am

Tickets Coming Soon!   The Puppetree   To celebrate the 75th Anniversary of Esphyr Slobodkina’s famous book of the hat seller and mischievous monkeys, The PuppeTree has rewritten and rebuilt our...

Goat on a Boat @ Bay Street presents Princess Pirate Pea
Category: Events July 21 at 11:00am

Tickets Coming Soon!   Crabgrass Puppets Join Crabgrass Puppet Theatre on a thrilling voyage chock full of sea monsters, sharks and side-splitting action! A pirate and a princess are each searching for hidden...

“Funny! I’m A Woman With Children…” Featuring Melissa Errico
Category: Events July 30 at 8:00pm

A very playful & vivacious, and musically diverse show!   A show about dating, romance, marriage and love & family; all with songs from such musicals as Gypsy, Hello Dolly, My Fair Lady, and Stephen...