Box Office

Box Office Hours

The Bay Street Box Office is open Tuesday through Saturday 11 am to 5 pm. 

Tickets may be purchased via:

  •  Phone: 631-725-9500
  •  Email:
  •  Online:
  •  Mail: Bay Street Theater P.O. Box 810 Sag Harbor, NY 11963, Attn: Box Office

The following handling fees apply:
$10 handling charge per order (not per ticket) for all phone, fax, email and mail orders.

Note: Tickets purchased at the Box Office window are not subject to handling charges.
        Online purchases are subject to additional processing fees.

You must show a photo I.D. or a credit card to pick up your tickets.


Click to view the seating chart (as a PDF file)


All sales are final. There are no refunds. There is a $10 fee to exchange per performance and is based upon availability. If you find you are unable to use your tickets, please consider offering them to a friend or family member. You may also consider donating your tickets back to us. You may receive a tax deductible receipt if the show sells out. Thank you.


Bay Street offers a standard 10% discount to senior citizens over the age of 65, Veterans with valid military ID and to students with a valid college ID. Students and seniors must mention this at time of purchase. Discounts are only available through the Box Office (not online)


Bay Street Theater offers a "STUDENT SUNDAY" matinee for Mainstage productions! Every Sunday, high school and college students can receive (1) FREE admission for the 2pm performance of the mainstage performance showing. If you have a valid student I.D call the Bay Street Box Office at 631-725-9500 to reserve your free student ticket! 


Special group rates for 20 or more people are available. For more information, please call the Box Office at 631-725-9500.


Bay Street Theatre Gift Certificates make a wonderful gift and can be issued in any denomination. For information or to purchase Gift Cards please contact the Box Office.

Click Here For Directions To Bay Street Theater